Blog

  • The Desperation of Lectures

    The Desperation of Lectures

    Why do lectures stop working on kids? Dr. Ray explains why parents slide into long, repeated lectures, what teenagers told him bothers them most, and why shorter ones are more likely to be absorbed.

    “Lectures. They didn’t like lectures.”

    My second book was titled “Back to the Family.” I did it in conjunction with Akron Children’s Hospital. A friend of mine, who was vice president of marketing at the hospital, orchestrated it. He had an idea that he was going to ask the national state teachers of the year in all 50 states, “Can you describe some very strong families that you have come across in your years of teaching?” Obviously, to be a state teacher of the year you have to love the profession and be pretty much involved in it. So he figured they were pretty good identifiers of solid families, and it turned out very much so.

    The book more or less taps into their ideas regarding discipline, communication, religion, marriage. It was a broad-range look at parenting. Wherever possible, we interviewed the kids, the older ones, maybe 13, 14 on up, and some were pretty insightful. We asked them, under the communication chapter I think it was, “What do your parents do that most bothers you, that most frustrates you?” Keep in mind, these were not families that were pathological by any stretch. We didn’t hear, “Oh, I just hate when the cops come here before breakfast. Oh, my mom, she hurt her arm so she can’t really throw plates at my dad like she used to. She has to throw with her left arm and sometimes she misses.”

    You know what we heard? It’s going to come as no surprise to those of you who have teenagers. Lectures. They didn’t like lectures. Now, what is a lecture? We grownups have a very broad-based definition. To us, a lecture is anything that goes on for more than 24 minutes or is repetitive six to eight times. To the kids, a lecture is anything that is a compound sentence of more than seven words. One that begins with, “You know, young lady, when I was your age,” or “We’re going to have a little talk about this, young man.”

    The desperation behind the lecture

    Now, am I saying don’t lecture? Of course not. I’m a parent. It’s part of the passage of being a parent. But I think there’s a certain desperation to lectures that can creep in. We so much want the kids to understand why we do what we do, the reasoning behind our Neanderthal decisions, as they see it. So we explain. We want to get through, and maybe one explanation from one angle isn’t enough, so we try different angles. We recall our own childhood. We draw moral parallels. There’s nothing wrong with this, but it does follow the law of diminishing returns.

    There comes a point in that lecture, usually somewhere around the 90-second mark, where they’re blanking out. You can see it in their eyes. Lecture number 602: “When I was your age, I was grateful for what little I had.” Part of the reason we go on is that we think we’re not being understood. They’re not getting this. Or maybe it’s a unique piece of misconduct, something they don’t routinely do that comes from left field, so you figure, “We better talk about this.”

    And again, do not mishear me. I am not saying that as a parent you don’t talk about these things. What I’m saying is, especially if this is stuff that is recurrent. For example, he has a tendency to belittle his little sister. She’s 11, he’s 14, and he takes every chance to poke at her. Now you’ve talked about this with him, but you feel compelled every so often to launch into a lecture again on why this isn’t good. Lectures one and two, you made yourself heard. Lectures 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, it’s fading. He’s enduring it. I wouldn’t go so far as to say you’re wasting your breath, but it’s close. It’s very close. And I know this would be hard to believe, but I don’t really like wasted words. “But then, Dr. Ray, you shouldn’t have your radio show.” Okay, easy.

    “Keep it short and sweet”

    Lectures come out of the desperate need to make sure they absorb our moral lesson, our social lesson, what we’re trying to teach, so that when they’re 23 they don’t have to learn the hard way. I got that part. I truly do. But at some point, you keep it short and sweet and you make your case. “I’m not letting you go to the mall because you’re 13 years old and it’s unsupervised. And I know that your friend Snake is allowed to go along with his brother Conan, but I just don’t think it’s smart.” Now you’ve explained it.

    When they try to get you to prolong your lecture, it’s not that they want to hear more reasons so that they can finally say, “Well, Mother, thank you. Had you stopped explaining this to me at the 24-minute mark, I don’t think I really would have understood. But because you kept on for another 18 minutes after that, I saw the light. It’s so clear to me now.”

    Pick and choose your lectures. If you’ve been over the same subject many times, a good rule of thumb is to make each ensuing lecture a little shorter. Watch out for the cues that they’re glazing over. It’s a deer, and your headlights are on bright. You’re not getting there. In fact, this is one thing you might want to ponder: are you actually losing ground? The more lectures, probably the less likely the lectures are absorbed.


    For more on discipline that sticks, Dr. Ray’s book Discipline That Lasts a Lifetime is a good next read.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • The Step by Step of Parental Estrangement

    The Step by Step of Parental Estrangement

    Why are so many adult children cutting off their parents? It is one of the most common problems Dr. Ray hears on the radio and in his office: faithful parents shut out by their grown kids, sometimes kept from their grandchildren. In this audio blog he lays out the chain of events he sees again and again.

    “Common, so common, so very common”

    If you’ve listened to this program at all, or ever sat in my office invisible, you would know that one of the far more common problems I deal with is parents who have been estranged, shut off, excommunicated by their young adults or even their middle-aged adults. Common, so common, so very common.

    A couple of weeks ago on this program I had an article that talked about this from a secular psychology perspective. It said a lot of young adults are writing off their parents. “Rightfully so!” was the tone of the article. Because, it said, what used to be looked at as just faulty parenting, struggling parenting, or just human parenting, we now realize is a lot more pathological. That was the tone of the article. It was awful.

    The chain of events behind estrangement

    These are generalizations, but here’s how it typically goes.

    1. The parents believe; the kids don’t. The older generation is more religious, and that’s borne out by the stats. Something like 40 percent of Gen Z, up to about age 27 or 28, are “nones.” Not sister nuns. They are nones of no religion. That has plateaued, and there are even little spurts of younger people embracing the faith, young men more so than young women. So the folks I hear from are by and large more religious, and their young adult children by and large are not.

    2. The kids aren’t content, and they look for someone to blame. To the degree that these young adults are not content in their lives, they make bad decisions. Especially in their thirties and forties, there is often a history of relationship problems, life problems, struggle. They’re not settled individuals. They’re unhappy, they’re discontent, they’re anxious. And of course they look for someone to blame, and the easiest target is their parents. “You did this to me.”

    3. Discontent leads to therapy. The percentage of adults in America who have at least tried therapy is over 50 percent. So it stands to reason: the more discontent, the more likely you are to approach a therapist.

    4. The therapy focuses on the self. In general, therapists practice a very secular type of psychology: it is most important that the individual feel at peace in their existence. If anybody is rattling that peace, then we have to consider separation from those peace disturbers, which oftentimes are parents.

    So we start out with religious parents who raise the kids pretty much in religion. The kids shed religion and want no part of it. They’re shaped by the culture, and they look at their parents like throwbacks: I don’t like your religious views. I don’t like your morals. I don’t like your politics. I don’t like the way you look at life. And you screwed me up.

    They go to therapy, and the therapist, listening to how they describe their parents, says, “Wow, you need to put some distance between you and those folks. From what you’re describing, they sound toxic. Have you set boundaries? Maybe for your own mental well-being you need some distance from them.”

    That’s where individual therapy goes. It focuses on the self, whereas Christianity focuses on the other. So there you have it: a confirmation that I’m not the one who needs to look at myself and what I’ve done to my parents. My parents have done this to me, and the therapist says so. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve come across that chain of events.

    “Unprecedented in human history”

    It’s only slowly starting to become apparent. I noticed this years ago. Dennis Prager was talking once, before his accident, about how many calls he got from older parents who said: I have no relationship with my young adult or middle-aged kids. I can’t see my grandkids. They don’t want me in their lives. I’ve tried to reach out. I’ve tried to apologize for whatever, but they don’t want to hear it.

    I read a column by Dennis Prager about this, and I thought: finally, somebody in the secular world is noticing that this is happening. I believe it is unprecedented in human history, that the next generation, in such huge numbers, looks back on the generation that raised them and says, “Ew! You’re pathological!” An interesting, interesting generational dynamic.


    Facing this in your own family? Dr. Ray answers parents’ hardest questions about faith and grown children in Family Faith Under Fire: Practical Answers to Everyday Challenges.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • Phrases that Make Kids Anxious & Parents Neurotic

    Phrases that Make Kids Anxious & Parents Neurotic

    Which everyday phrases make kids anxious, and are parents getting too neurotic about them? Dr. Ray reacts to an article in which a psychologist warns against seven common phrases, and tells you where he agrees and where he does not.

    “Psychologists warn”

    This is one of my problems with these articles, and they’re all over the place. This is one of the reasons why parents are so insecure and nervous, and dare I say sometimes neurotic, about raising children. The article says, “Psychologists warn.” There you are. Look out. Don’t do this. You ruin your kid. Are they saying, “Don’t scream at your kid”? Are they saying, “Don’t beat him”? Are they saying, “Don’t completely ignore him”? No, no, no, no, no. When we psychologists warn you about stuff, a lot of times it’s stuff you would normally do and that many people do in the normal course of parenthood. But then we’ve decided this ain’t good, because we’ve got letters after our name, you know.

    The article says psychologists warn about these seven “nice” phrases, and they have that in quotes, from parents and grandparents. Here is how you create anxiety in kids. So we warn you, and then we say what you might naturally do, or what people have always done, and then we tell you, “Don’t you realize the deleterious effects?”

    Now, who am I to critique an article? Well, I’m probably equal to the person who wrote it in experience anyway. It says psychologists say that the desire to protect our children and grandchildren is instinctual. Well, you don’t need psychologists to tell you that. God tells you that. Human history tells you that. Common sense tells you that. “It’s a good thing I told you that, isn’t it? That you could protect your children because that’s instinctual.” Oh, thanks.

    “It feels like good parenting”

    This is a woman named Dr. Amy Todey. I don’t know how to pronounce it. She’s a psychologist. Here she says, “When we caution a child, we rush to reassure them or gently nudge them away from fear or sadness, it feels like good parenting, it feels caring.” Okay, note the unspoken. It feels like it. Unspoken is, it’s not.

    Dr. Todey and other psychologists warn that these phrases we use to support kids can “unintentionally,” see, that’s a scary word, you don’t even know you’re doing it, make children think the world is more threatening than it is. This is why parents are so nervous and neurotic. It’s like, man, I’m messing my kid up and I don’t even know it. Now, I agree with that part. You don’t want a kid to think the world is more threatening than it is. And if you let them watch a lot of TV, they’re going to think that, and that’s going to do a lot more damage than these phrases.

    The article goes on: “As a result, they may engage in less developmentally appropriate risk taking and problem solving, which can make it harder to build their emotional resilience. They need to handle the things life throws their way.” I got that part. Yeah, our kids are a little wobbly emotionally because we so much hover over them and shield them from too many things. I used to call it, in one of my books, bulldozer parenting. That’s true. But here’s where I struggle with this: you’re not going to avoid all that just by not using these phrases. That’s just dumb.

    The seven phrases

    The psychologists say it’s best for parents and grandparents to steer clear of these seven “nice” phrases that can create anxiety in kids. They reveal which phrases to avoid and what to say instead, and they reveal the one phrase children need to hear more often. As far as I’m concerned, the one phrase they need to hear more often is “I love you.” But that’s okay. Let’s find out. Here’s the seven that create anxiety. It reminds me of that old bit by George Carlin, the seven things you’re not allowed to say on TV. Well, poor Carlin. He’s long since out of touch, because all those things are now said on TV relentlessly.

    Be careful. Can’t say that. Nope. Don’t say “be careful.” Don’t worry, everything will be fine. I know you’ll do well. I’m proud of you. And here’s the one I most disagree with: I just want you to be happy. Well, if that’s the goal, you’re going to miss out on a lot of things more important, like virtues and contentment. You’re my whole world. Don’t say that, you realize you’re making them anxious and neurotic. And be good.

    Now, one could say these are kind of fluff phrases. They don’t really mean a whole lot. “I know you’ll do well”: the kid will think, well, I don’t know if I’ll do well or not. You didn’t take the test for me. Or “I’m proud of you”: it implies you’ve got to achieve for me to be proud of you. I got the thinking behind all this. “You’re my whole world”: they’ll say that puts an enormous pressure on the kid, Atlas shrugged with the world on his shoulders. You’re none of that to your kid. I can see where some of these phrases would not be the most substantive things to say, but in terms of creating anxiety, how often do you have to say them?

    By the way, if I say “be good” when I’m dropping him off at grandma’s house, what if I’m implying you need to be good for grandma or else I’m going to do something about it? That could be my code phrase, right? But I know what they’re saying. They’re saying “be good” implies that I really don’t expect you to be good, or it implies that to get my approval you have to be good. Or worse, “good” is a value word, right? You say it this way: have acceptable behavior, make good choices.

    “I’m right here with you”

    All right, let me finish it up here. The one phrase that you should tell kids, really? “I’m right here with you.” Hmm. Well, I could see that with kids who are down and out, or feeling sad or unsure, threatened, bullied, whatever it is. Yeah, I got your back. I’m with you. That’s great. I like that one a lot. I’m not sure I’d say it to a four-year-old who’s melting down and kicking stuff. “I’m right here with you.” I wonder what they do about that one.

    She closes with this: “Kids need to feel grounded in connection and attunement.” Who talks like that? “This phrase tells them they’re not handling the moment alone and that their feelings make sense and are valid.” Well, my feeling that I want to punch my brother in the head, I don’t think makes a whole lot of sense, and I don’t think it’s valid. It’s not a good feeling. “Well, no, Dr. Ray, that’s not what they’re saying. They’re saying the anger makes sense.” Does it? Does anger make sense when it’s based upon a situation that really shouldn’t foster anger? My little sister just burped, so I’m angry at her. That anger doesn’t make sense there.

    So this is why I close. This is why so many parents are getting so neurotic about raising kids. This is a classic example of all the stuff we experts warn you against. And if you don’t listen to us, don’t blame me. If your kids are going to be on Springer, I tried to tell you. I’m done. And I know you folks will call in. You’ll do well, and I’ll be proud of you when you call in. You’re my whole show. So be careful and be good.


    If parenting advice like this leaves you doubting yourself, Dr. Ray talks about that in You’re a Better Parent Than You Think!

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • Look and Listen!

    Look and Listen!

    Why do people start their answers with “look” and “listen”? Dr. Ray talks about a communication habit he notices in interviewees and sometimes in parents, and wonders what is behind it.

    “Listen” and “Look”

    I have noticed that when people are asked a question, and this is particularly true of pundits, perhaps political figures, there is a communicative habit that’s ugly. I think it’s easily done even in normal conversation, and the implications of it are not good. What am I referring to? Let’s say you ask me a question and you say, “Ray, I want to get your opinion on my 17-year-old daughter.” And I start my answer with, “Listen.” Now that’s very commanding, isn’t it? That struck me, because I’ve heard an awful lot of interviewees begin their answer that way. Or a parallel word: “Look.” In other words, I am dictating to you to pay attention.

    I don’t know why this is so common. One of my explanations is that we tend, by osmosis, to pick up on speaking styles. The word “well” is used constantly to answer any question. I would say at least 80 percent of the time, when someone is being interviewed on radio or TV about a subject they have experience in, they’ll start out with “Well.” But “look” and “listen” are particularly pushy. In other words, “Look and listen.” They imply, “You need to pay attention to me.”

    I think it’s as though, if I don’t say “listen,” they’re not going to listen. Or, I don’t know what I want them to look at. Apparently, look at my reasoning. You could say “Think,” or “Pay attention,” or “Watch out.” All of which say, “I’m going to say something really important to you now, and you need to focus on it.”

    “Well, being a shrink”

    Now, some might say, “Kind of being a little picky here about language, aren’t you, Ray?” Well, being a shrink, what you’ve got to do is listen to language. That’s the coin of the realm in therapy or counseling. Trying to understand somebody, you’ve got to listen to the words they use. You’ve got to listen to how they use the words. You’ve got to, between the lines, try to figure out what they’re saying. You’ve got to connect this sentence to a sentence they said 12 minutes ago. You have to hyper-focus on the way they phrase things.

    It’s very hard for me. My wife sometimes will be watching something on TV, and she’ll look at me, because she’ll know I’m just getting ready to comment on this. She’ll say, “Ray,” and I go, “Yeah, okay, okay, okay.”

    There’s a certain emphatic pronunciation to both of those words. It’s not “please look” or “would you listen?” No, no, no, it’s “listen,” and I can’t help wondering what the motive is for using those words. Is it just a habit, just a way of talking? Is it to fill up a little bit of time until you formulate the thought you were going to say? Or is it something more? Is it stressing that my opinion needs to be taken into account here, because it’s very accurate, formidable, and something you should seriously consider? I don’t know. I just thought about that. I made a little note here in my book: comment on starting answers with “look” and “listen.”

    Sometimes parents do that. Lecturers, you notice that? Kid does something, and we want to try to straighten out their thinking on it. “Now listen to me.” We do that. “You look here, young man.” I guess those are kind of variety words, and you can use them in a bunch of contexts. But I’ve got to take a break here. So when I get back, I hope you’ll listen.


    Dr. Ray has plenty more on how we talk to each other in How to Get Along with Almost Everybody.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • Understanding Does Not Equal Agreement

    Understanding Does Not Equal Agreement

    If my teen understands why I do what I do, will she agree? Dr. Ray says understanding does not equal agreement, and explains why that is such a frustration for parents.

    “She does understand. She doesn’t like it.”

    A parent will be in my office, say for example with a teen, and the parent will lament, “I wish I could just get her to understand why we do what we do. We’re not trying to be mean, we’re trying to raise her well. I just don’t think she understands. And if she understood, I think our parenting would be easier. I’d have more peace at the house.”

    At that point I might turn to the young lady or young man and say, “Would you explain in your own words, for the court, why your mother does what she does? Why your mother, for example, won’t let you have a smartphone yet?” And at that point the kid will take up the mantle, turn to Mom, and with articulation far superior to my own say, “I know that you believe I’m just trying to be difficult, and I realize you’re not trying to be difficult. I realize you want to do what is good for me, and this will help me a lot as I get older. I see the way some of my friends are being raised and it’s not good. Even though I want to do what they want to do and you’re stopping me, in the long run I’m probably going to appreciate it.” And she goes on and on, explaining her understanding of why her mother does what she does, probably more perfectly than the mother could.

    At that point, I keep smelling salts in my top-left drawer. I go to Mom and put them underneath her nose and arouse her after she’s fainted on the floor. And I ask Mom, “What do you think?” Mom says, “I don’t believe it. She seems to totally understand.” And I say, “You thought she was not being cooperative or battling you because she didn’t understand?” “Yes. I thought if she understood, she’d at least be more agreeable about this stuff.” “Well, do you think she understands now?” “Well, unless she was just mouthing the words, at least she seems to understand what I’ve been trying to tell her.” I said, “Well, Mom, you are absolutely right. She does understand. She doesn’t like it and she doesn’t agree with it. There’s where the problem is.”

    “Understanding does not equal agreement”

    This is kind of like the old philosophers who thought that if you had proper knowledge, you would have proper conduct. This is where I think Christianity corrected them. Proper knowledge does not necessarily lead to proper conduct, because self-interest is involved, or fallen human nature, as we Christians would call it. I can have all the knowledge in the world. I can know completely and totally why I shouldn’t smoke. I can recite a beautiful dissertation on all the problems of smoking and still smoke. “So, Dr. Ray, that’s different. That’s a physical addiction.” But I can recite all the reasons why I should forgive my mother-in-law and still not do it. Understanding does not equal agreement.

    I think that’s a frustration for parents so much. They’ll say, “How do I get him to listen? How do I get him to see?” Well, you get him to listen and see by telling them. But the next step is not that it’s going to be all fixed. Many people will say, “My mother-in-law, I just can’t get her to understand why I homeschool or why I’m raising my kids the way I am. She’s always got comments. How do I get her to understand?” I go, she probably can understand. She just doesn’t like it. That’s very different. I think it’s much easier to make somebody understand than it is to agree, if they don’t want to agree.

    I can understand all kinds of things. If somebody says to me, “I believe that a woman can choose whether to kill that baby in her womb or not,” I can understand their logic, however flawed I think it is. I can understand it. I don’t agree with it. I can understand why kids decide when they’re 19 years old to drift from the faith. I don’t accept it or like it. That seems to be a misconception that’s so prominent now: if I can get someone to understand me, they’ll be more open to agreeing with me. Maybe. But if in the end they don’t want to agree with you, no matter how much they understand why you think and do the way you do, then that’s not going to happen. That’s so hard for us to accept.

    Now, I can understand why you don’t accept it, but I don’t agree with why you don’t accept it. So I understand why the folks at EWTN and Ave Maria say, “I’ve got to take a break right now.” Okay, they’ve got to have breaks. They’ve got certain time cues they have to have. I got that part. I don’t agree with it! I said I don’t want to take a break. I’ve got more to say.


    For parents of teens who understand the rules and still push back, Dr. Ray’s book Standing Strong: Good Discipline Makes Great Teens is a good place to go next.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • Benign Underparenting is Good

    Benign Underparenting is Good

    Is it actually good to parent your kids a little less? Dr. Ray reads from an article on “mindful underparenting,” looks at what parents say they want most for their children, and adds a story about boredom.

    “I just want them to be happy”

    This was sent to me by Janet Clark. Some of you might know she has been, many, many times, especially in the northeastern Ohio area, my role-play co-actress in the different things we do on “Living Right with Dr. Ray.” We usually have an informal role play to try to make some point about life or living.

    Let me preface this. I was watching a sitcom once, and the parent, when talking to the spouse about her desire for her kids, said, “I want them to be happy. I just want them to be happy.” At the time, of course, I can’t shut my mouth. I make these comments, which probably drives my wife crazy. I’ve got to make psychological comments. I said, “Happy. So that’s the priority here, happy.” And I thought to myself, I wonder, if I pay attention, how many of the programs we watch on TV, if the topic comes up, have a parent saying, “I just want my kids to be happy.”

    Well, I have been confirmed, well, not sacramentally, in my observation. A recent Pew Center study reports that parents want above all else for their children financial independence and a satisfying job. Okay, that’s one and two. Graduating from college was a distant third. Getting married and having children of their own, according to this article, and I like the way they said this, pulled up the rear. Being moral, finding meaning in life, or practicing a religion did not appear on the list of priorities.

    How is this relevant? Well, when you compare it to other survey data, which basically says that our young people, the Gen Z years and maybe the Millennials, have the highest recorded rates of anxiety and depression of any group surveyed, the article says: with such external and materialistic aspirations for their children, it is not surprising, though it’s a sad irony, that these same parents reported they are most worried about their children’s mental health. These same parents want financial independence and a satisfying job first and foremost for their kids, with getting married way, way, way down, and being moral, finding meaning in life, religion, not even showing up on the radar.

    “Parents should ignore their children more often”

    This is an interesting suggestion by a psychologist named Darby Saxbe. I said “the guy,” but, sorry about that, Darby is female. Boy, this is really bad for the gentle parenting folk. Quote: “Parents should ignore their children more often.” Now, this makes for an ear-catching phrase, but here’s what she means. Not so much that the kids should be ignored, as that they be de-centered. She argues that today’s frantic, child-centered, helicopter parenting is, quote, “based on assumptions about what our children need to thrive that are not supported by evidence from most of human history until the last few decades.” Parents practiced what she calls “mindful underparenting.”

    Now, this allows kids to, quote, “spend lots of time with their parents but not usually as the parents’ primary focus, sometimes bored, sometimes engaged.” I’m quoting her now. These kids spend much of their time observing adults doing adult things. Now, this is a shocker, and I can see this. She says, quote, “Your average daycare is probably closer to the average historical childhood experience than today’s overstimulated boy or girl at the center of attention.” Whoo.

    Let’s see if there’s anything else she says. They go on to talk about how kids observe us, and we are still the greatest influence. It says here, “The good news is that among all possible influences, parents exert far and away the greatest influence on their children’s religious outcomes.” Well, let me qualify that. If they so intentionally do, they can exert the greatest possible influence. All right, there you go. There’s a lot more she says, but let’s leave it at that.

    “Children need boring time”

    By the way, just as a P.S. here, my second book was called “Back to the Family,” and we interviewed strong families in all 50 states. We were talking about spending time with your kids, and one mother observed, she said, “Children need boring time. They need to have time just to look at stuff, not the computer screen, outside stuff, curiosity stuff. They need time.”

    One time I said this to a priest from Africa. We were talking about raising kids, and I said, “A lot of parents hear from their children, ‘I’m bored.’” He looked at me, puzzled. He said, “What is that word?” I said, “Bored.” He says, “Yes?” I said, “Well, it means kind of like you don’t really have anything to do.” And then he said, “How could you not have anything to do?” They did not have a word in his language, in his tribal language, for “boring.” Interesting, isn’t it?


    On the question of what parents should put first, Dr. Ray’s book Raising Upright Kids in an Upside-Down World picks it up.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • The most common and wrong adjective leveled at children…

    The most common and wrong adjective leveled at children…

    Is my child really strong-willed? Dr. Ray explains why he thinks “strong-willed” is the most overused and misleading label parents put on kids. He covers why it exploded and what he suggests a parent do first if they are convinced they have one.

    “The most common adjective leveled at children”

    I have come to the conclusion that the most common adjective leveled at children, pretty much of all ages, is also a very misleading one. It’s an unfair one, in most cases. What word am I alluding to? Strong-willed.

    Years ago, James Dobson, psychologist for Focus on the Family, wrote the book The Strong-Willed Child. I think it was in the 80s, maybe even the 70s. Of course, most people think they have at least one strong-willed child.

    Now, why do I think that adjective is so misleading, so heavily overused? And by the way, it has variants. He is so oppositional. She has a mind of her own. Very high maintenance. Challenging child, very challenging child. Seven going on 17. We have a difficult child, according to our pediatrician. Difficult child, folks, is redundant.

    So why did these words explode? My mother-in-law had five children, one of them my wife. She said to my wife one time, “I don’t remember talking with other parents when I was raising the kids about how difficult and challenging and strong-willed the kids were.” And I said, “Ma, I think that’s a new phenomenon.”

    Why the label exploded

    Let me give you a couple of reasons. One is the onslaught of experts giving you all their theories and notions about how you are to talk to children and be gentle with children and reason with children and use I-messages and not U-messages and use sticker systems and set up win-win scenarios. When you try doing these things, they may work for a small percentage of kids. I’m not saying they don’t, but they don’t work for the majority of kids at all.

    And it looks like the kids are unusually difficult. If this stuff isn’t working, you obviously don’t have a normal child. You’ve got somebody a little more stubborn, a little more strong-willed, a little more challenging, a little more oppositional, a little mind of her own.

    I’m not saying you don’t be gentle with a kid, of course you do, but you have to have authority, calm, quiet, confident authority. And if you don’t, the kid’s going to be very difficult for you. There’s just no question about that. It is a direct relationship. He is going to be pushy, challenging, contrary, argumentative. Excuse me for saying “he,” but most behavioral problems are boys.

    Second, much of the time when parents come into my office, I ask them, “Do you think you have a strong-willed child?” Oh yes, very, the strongest will of all my children. My other children are not like this. What’s the school say? They don’t see any of this. He’s there six hours. That teacher doesn’t have a fraction of your authority. So how is it that the teacher gets cooperation, thinks he’s a delight, loves having him in class, and you think he’s strong-willed?

    Third, to quote G.K. Chesterton, fallen human nature, or sin nature, I forget what Chesterton called it, is the one doctrine of Christianity that has abundant empirical evidence. Abundant.

    “The strongest will of my kids was not stronger than his mother”

    So those are some explanations. There’s more. The biggest one is basically parents. I had ten children. I didn’t consider any of them strong-willed. Am I delusional? No, I think there’s a straightforward explanation. The strongest will of my kids was not stronger willed than his mother. That’s it.

    Yes, they varied in their strength of will. Of course they do. They vary in the way they challenge. They vary in the way they learn from experience. Some go to the corner twice, and that’s it. Others go to the corner 264 times and go, “Hey, wait a minute. So you’re saying if I do that, I’m going to go to the corner? Aha! I get it now.”

    Now, are there strong-willed children? Yes, but I haven’t seen many of them in my career. If you want me to put a percentage on it, under 1 percent. There are those who are just bound and determined, bent on resisting rules and limits no matter how good their parents are.

    But many of the parents who come into my office think they’re very good at disciplining, and this kid is just hell-bent on challenging them. As we talk over the hour or two or however long the sessions are, we find out there’s a lot they could be doing differently. Not because they’re bad people, but because they’ve been making some bad moves in handling this kid. That’s all. Then they tell me two, three, four weeks later, and I ask, “Do you think he’s still strong-willed?” Well, I’m not sure I’d use that word anymore.

    If you think you have a strong-willed kid, if you’re convinced of it, the first thing you do is size up your own parenting. You say, “Okay, wait a minute. I think I’m a good disciplinarian. I think I’m consistent. I think I follow through. I think I have standards.” Okay, I’m not going to argue with any of that. But typically, and maybe you need some help sorting through it, you can either come to a guy like me as a client, or you can pick up one of my parenting books that will explain all this and help you realize, “Wait a minute, there are things I could be doing differently, and then let’s see if he’s still so strong-willed.”


    For the discipline basics behind all this, Dr. Ray’s book Discipline That Lasts a Lifetime is a good place to start.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • He’s a Special Child

    He’s a Special Child

    Should I go easy on discipline because my child has been through a hard time? Dr. Ray describes the “He’s a Special Child” trap, where parents of kids hurt by life back off on limits. He explains why love and support are one thing and lowering the standard for behavior is another.

    A little guy with a hearing problem

    I consulted for several years to a number of Head Start programs. Basically I did evaluations and consulted with the teachers. I remember one year we had a little guy, about four, four and a half. He had significant hearing problems, to the point where it really affected his interaction with other kids. This little guy was an extreme behavior problem. He was uncooperative. He threw major league resistant fits. Very difficult.

    One interpretation, and I think this is one that would be glommed onto by someone looking for a lot of complicated psychological reasons, would be that he’s frustrated. The poor little guy can’t interact with people, so his emotions get the better of him and he reacts. I’m not ruling that out. That could be a part of it.

    But as I met with the parents, I found that they felt very guilty about life ripping him off, that he couldn’t hear normally. As a consequence they didn’t want to put limits on his conduct or discipline him, because they felt he was so frustrated by his deficiency in hearing that holding him accountable for some of the nasty stuff he was doing would be mean-spirited and unpleasant. So what you had was a little guy whose conduct was more of a handicap for him than his hearing handicap.

    “He’s a Special Child”

    My first book was titled You’re a Better Parent Than You Think. It sprang from my experience at a mental health center, where I quickly became the parenting go-to guy and saw an awful lot of parents. Good people! Insecure, second-guessing, irresolute, lacking authority, frustrated by their kids. A lot of it was because they didn’t allow themselves to have legitimate, fair, helpful, healthy authority. One of the chapters in the book was called “How to Talk Yourself Out of Authority.” One of the sections of that chapter was “He’s a Special Child.” Here’s how it works.

    You have a child, and it doesn’t have to be a six-year-old, it can be a fifteen-year-old, who you believe has been ripped off by life. One of the more common rip-offs is a divorce. The custodial parent feels very badly for the child because the mom or the dad is not a consistent part of their life anymore. Or you have a child on the autistic spectrum, with a developmental problem that makes it more difficult to interact appropriately with others. Or a child who’s developmentally delayed, who’s ten but functions like a seven-year-old overall. Anything that brings a child out of the realm of normal, unhindered development is a risk. A lot of parents say, “Life has not been fair to my child, therefore I have to understand what he’s dealing with, and therefore I have to be very loose in implementing any discipline, because of his overall frustration level and his struggle to deal with his handicap, whatever that might be.”

    In situations like that, I’m quick to counsel parents. On one hand, you do understand that this child may have his own special issues in learning responsibility, learning self-control, learning to treat people with respect, acting appropriately socially, because of his particular developmental, emotional, and sometimes transient issues. If a parent dies, I’ve had that a lot. I’ve seen some severe behavior problem kids in my office whose parent died when they were seven, eight, and nine, and the surviving parent, now that the kid’s 15, essentially stopped disciplining because they felt so terrible that this kid was hurting so badly about losing a mom or dad.

    I counsel them: it is one thing to give emotional support. More hugs, more kisses, more positives, more time. That is one thing. But you do not do a child any favors, any help, any good by saying, “Because life has been tough on you as I see it, I can’t add to it by expecting you to act appropriately or respectfully or socially right.” I’ve seen so many kids, because of that, become very difficult young adults. And it isn’t because of the original handicap or life struggle. It’s because the parents backed off in teaching and socializing and moralizing this child.

    Don’t do it. It’s one thing to be hurting because of your particular situation, but that is not a justification for being nasty or disrespectful or hurtful or mean-spirited to other people. They still have to be held accountable with loving discipline.

    “Ray, you big dummy!”

    When we adopted our twins, they were undisciplined. They were four years old and had not been disciplined well for the first four years of their lives, and the son especially was just out of control. I remember one time lying in bed and saying to my wife, “Honey, I don’t know. Maybe we ought to loosen up here with him.” And she said, very supportively and lovingly, “Ray, you big dummy!” Okay, she didn’t say that, but I could read it in her eyes.

    She said, “We can’t do that. We’ll give them more hugs, more kisses, tell them how much we love them, but it wouldn’t be fair to them to lower the standards for them that we don’t lower for the other kids.” And she was right. So they did get more discipline in the beginning because they just had so many things that were socially inappropriate and out of control. But with time, they settled in. It did take a while, but they did settle in.

    My wife is exactly right. She said, “Ray, just because they’ve had a very difficult first four years doesn’t mean we turn around and say, ‘Well, okay, we can’t ask you to treat your sister nicely.’” One of the biggest traps parents fall into is “he’s a special child,” and therefore my discipline becomes permissive or lax or overlooking. It doesn’t help anybody.


    This idea comes straight from a chapter in Dr. Ray’s first book, You’re a Better Parent Than You Think!

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • Jesus Was Not a Good Man

    Jesus Was Not a Good Man

    Was Jesus just a good man or a good teacher? Dr. Ray, a psychologist, argues that “good man” is not a choice Jesus left open to us. He walks through why the apostles’ own lives and the content of Jesus’ teaching do not fit the theories that try to get around who he claimed to be.

    “Jesus was not a good man”

    Jesus was not a good man. You heard me right. Jesus was not a good man, if that’s all he was. If he were only a man, then he knew when he talked and acted like God that it was an act. He knew he wasn’t God. So really, he set people up to be punished and killed to follow him. If he truly thought he was God but he wasn’t, then he was similar to some of the people I used to assess at the state hospitals. He was crazy. He was either God, or he was something far worse.

    You can’t get around Jesus by saying he was a good man. That’s fascinating, because many of the intelligentsia, people at universities, folks who fancy themselves great thinkers, just declare, “Well, he was a good teacher, like Buddha, like Gandhi.” No, he wasn’t. He didn’t even know his identity if he wasn’t God. He was claiming to be something he wasn’t.

    So there’s no middle ground, as C.S. Lewis said. He didn’t intend to give us a middle ground. He either is who he said he is, or he’s a lot worse. He’s not a normal human being. That’s your choice.

    “Why are you going to be martyred for making stuff up?”

    Now, I have seen people try to get around this conundrum by saying that the stuff about him thinking and talking and acting like God, his followers put that in there. They wrote it in because they had to make him a little bigger than he was. He’s not just another rabbi guru. He’s getting a bunch of followers, getting thumbs up. We’ve got to make him bigger than he is if we have any chance of overthrowing the Roman Empire. We’ve got to go at this from a different angle. We can’t throw him over militarily, so we’ve got to figure out how to change hearts and minds. I know what we’ll do. We’ll make this guy God.

    That’s the thinking. I’ve heard that thinking. It’s a nice little speculative hypothesis by people who want to do away with having to make the decision regarding who Jesus was. But here’s a problem with that. We have pretty good historical evidence that the apostles, almost all of them, were martyred. You’re going to be martyred for making stuff up about a guy? You can give up your life for that?

    And here’s another thing. We know they traveled. Thomas, tradition tells us, was in India. Matthew, Africa. Wait a minute. If you’re trying to overthrow the Roman Empire, you don’t have to go to India. Nothing over there. What are you trying to preach? You’re trying to preach a lie that this guy was God? What for?

    So he either is who he said he is, or you can’t trust the Gospel as history. You don’t even have to trust it as God’s word. Just trust it as history. These guys wrote down the things he said and did, and you have to say that when they wrote it down, they wildly embellished it. And if you say that, you have to ask, like a good detective, what was their motive? Why? As far as we can tell, these guys were pretty faithful Jews. For them to declare that some guy was God, when they knew he wasn’t, they would be jeopardizing their eternal destiny. Jews didn’t do that. Jews were fearfully monotheistic. This makes no sense. None. Why would they jeopardize not only their souls but their lives? For what? To make up a bunch of stuff about this guy?

    Where is the craziness in his teaching?

    Here’s the other problem you have. Let’s just say he was crazy. Okay, then let’s look at what he said. Take away all the stuff where he was saying he was God, acting like God, talking like God. Just take his teachings, his parables. I’m a shrink. I’ve read them many times, not because I’m such a wonderful Bible scholar, but because I go to Mass. If you go to Mass for three years, you pretty much hear the whole Gospel.

    There’s not a whiff of craziness in what he talked about. Nothing. You would expect that if he’s crazy, this whole idea that “I’m God” would spill over into what he says about how to live your life. But it didn’t. What he said about how to live your life is sublime. It makes total sense. And whether psychology admits it or not, read my book, Jesus, The Master Psychologist. Research supports the kind of stuff Jesus said for more contented, stable, peace-filled living.

    So where’s the craziness in his teaching? Is this craziness only circumscribed in his self-identity? If you don’t know who you are, you are really crazy, because that is at the core of reality. Who are you? If Jesus said, “I’m God, that’s who I am,” then he’s crazy if he’s not God. Or he’s very calculating, if he knew he wasn’t God and figured, “I’ve got to get some followers. What’s the best way to do this?”

    But even that doesn’t make sense, because he’s not going to get followers by saying he’s God when he’s in a fiercely Jewish community that says, “Our God is one.” Why would you try to convince them otherwise? The only way he could convince them otherwise was to show it. He had to do things that they couldn’t account for. Miracles, signs, wonders, where they said, “How does he do this?” He’s claiming this, but yet he can do this. Even his enemies knew that. Even his enemies said, “Yeah, we’ll admit you do it, but you do it through the power of Satan.” And of course Jesus, as always, has a wonderful response. A couple of sentences, and he just shoots them down.

    So don’t let anybody tell your kids, if they go to college, or anybody you talk to, “Well, I’ll admit Jesus was a good man. He was a good teacher. He had a lot of nice ideas about how to live life.” You just look at them and say, “Well, you must not know much about the Gospels at all then.” Because that’s not even a possibility. He can’t have been just a good man.


    Dr. Ray makes the case for what Jesus taught in Jesus, the Master Psychologist: Listen to Him.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • Getting Cooperation from our Kids

    Getting Cooperation from our Kids

    Is it bribery to reward a child for going to bed cooperatively? Dr. Ray reacts to a podcast guest who said rewarding a four-year-old is far more effective than a consequence. He explains why he thinks it gets the order of cooperation and privileges backwards.

    What the podcast got wrong

    I listened to a fellow on a podcast last night. This guy has written some books on the formation of habits. It was good stuff, really was. He said a couple of things, though, that got me pondering.

    He used positive reinforcement, meaning putting a positive reaction or reward on something to increase the behavior that you want. And then he used the phrase “negative reinforcement” to mean putting a negative consequence on it. That’s not exactly right. I would have thought he would have known that. Negative reinforcement is the removal of something negative. So, for example, “If you do this, I will unground you.” That’s an example of negative reinforcement.

    But he said something that just makes me so uneasy, though I understand it because this is dominant psychological thinking. He said positive reinforcement is far more powerful than negative reinforcement. I think in the main that’s very true. However, the example he used gave me pause. He said if you want your four-year-old to go to bed, you say, “If you don’t go to bed cooperatively, tomorrow you lose your…” and then he named a device. My four-year-old wouldn’t have a device anyway, but that was the first place where I had a little trouble with it.

    He called that negative reinforcement: go to bed cooperatively, or you lose this. Then he said it would be far more effective, “twenty times more effective” I think was the phrase he used, to say, “If you go to bed cooperatively, I’m going to give you fifteen more minutes on your tablet tomorrow.”

    “It smells a little bit like bribery”

    I was ill at ease about that for several reasons. First of all, let’s just leave the tablet aside for a four-year-old, okay? That’s the first thing. Secondly, the implication, “I’m going to give you fifteen more minutes,” means how much time do you have to begin with? Now you’re giving them another fifteen? All right, those are really not the main issues.

    Here are the main ones for me. It would seem that you want to teach your children that cooperation, responsibility, and mature conduct are the condition for privileges and perks. In other words, your cooperation is what leads to the kinds of perks that you normally get. He chose to phrase the other side in terms of consequence. You should have used the word “punishment,” really. You can water it down by saying “consequence.”

    The other thing is this. It smells a little bit like bribery. If you cooperate in going to bed, if you don’t make this an hour and a half hassle, I’m going to give you something more. Well, why stop with that? Why not say, “Okay, I’ll let you stay up later tomorrow night”? I’ll let you watch an hour more TV. I’ll let you have two desserts instead of one. In other words, if you cooperate with me, I will pay you off. That just sits so badly with me in terms of trying to teach virtue.

    He was talking about establishing the habit. If you go to bed cooperatively, I will give you extra privileges. And I wanted to say, “Okay, are you going to do that every night? Are you basically going to say, ‘Every night I’m going to give you fifteen extra minutes on your tablet’?” I think he was really way off.

    Cooperation leads to perks and privileges

    Much of what he said was very helpful and useful. But again, I think he just reflected so much of the psychological thinking that is out there. I remember I got this when I was in grad school. Nothing but positive, nothing but positive. Reinforcement, reinforcement, reward, reward, reward. No consequences, no punishment. That was just pounded into us. And I remember being ill at ease then, before I even had forty years of experience with parents and kids.

    I think the main lesson you want to teach the kids is that cooperation leads to perks and privileges. That’s the order of things. It seems like he was reversing the order.

    Now, cooperation can lead to extra perks and privileges. You can say, “You know what? You were so cooperative last night. Tell you what I’m going to do today.” You can do that, but it’s a random thing, and it’s after the fact. It’s not before. If we go out to the restaurant and you’re really good, I’ll let you have extra dessert. Well, it would seem to me that getting dessert is a privilege, a perk. Heck, going out to eat in a restaurant is a perk. But if you’re pleasant and cooperative, yes, you’ll get the standard. We’re all going to have dessert and you’ll get it too. But if you’re not, that’s a privilege. Responsibility, cooperation, and pleasantness beget the stuff of your age. I think the other way just reverses it.


    Dr. Ray lays out his approach to discipline that builds character in Raising Upright Kids in an Upside-Down World.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • How do feelings change?

    How do feelings change?

    Can you change how you feel by changing how you think? Dr. Ray uses a Mark Twain quote and his own experience to show how thinking changes over the years, and how feelings follow. He applies it to a parent whose grown child has left the faith.

    “Has your thinking changed since age 14?”

    Mark Twain supposedly said this: “When I was 14, my father was so ignorant I could barely stand to have the old man around, but when I got to be 21, I was astonished at how much the old man learned in seven years.” Here’s the question that quote prompts. Has your thinking changed since age 14? How about since age 21? At that time you were pretty sure of the way you looked at things, right? What’s changed since? Probably a whole lot.

    You just don’t look at things now as you did then. Whether it’s religion, politics, life, emotions, people, or relationships, your thinking has radically shifted. What changed it? Was it reality? Was it personal experience? How about making mistakes, listening to other people, even your old man? Your thinking changes all the time.

    Thinking changes, and feelings follow

    So when people say to me, “I can’t help it, that’s the way I feel,” I’m tempted to say, “Well, wait, how did your thinking change from twenty years ago about all kinds of stuff?” Obviously you felt a certain way then. How come you don’t feel that way now? Because slowly, sometimes by getting hit with a two-by-four, you realize the way you were thinking is not good, doesn’t help you, causes problems for you, makes you feel bad, creates emotions that you don’t like. You start the process of saying, “I don’t want to think like that anymore. I want to accept that I can’t change that person. For years I felt terrible because that person was a certain way and I couldn’t do anything about it, but I don’t feel so terrible anymore.”

    Why? “Well, I guess I’ve just accepted that I can’t do anything about it.” How’d you accept it? What did you do? It wasn’t magic. You changed your thinking. You kept reinforcing to yourself, “I can’t do anything about that.” In the beginning you thought you could. Later on maybe you realized you couldn’t, but you were upset, devastated, frustrated because you so wanted to change that other person. You were desperate to change that other person. There’s got to be a way. Over time you realized, “No, I can’t. I tried every way I knew how. I even called that dude on the radio, Ray Guarendi.” He said, “Are you sure you can change that person?”

    So you came to accept, to your own peace, that you can’t do anything about that situation. Obviously your emotions changed with it. You’re not as disgruntled, not as unhappy, not as frustrated, not as ill at ease or lacking peace about the whole scenario. Because as you analyzed it, thought about it, and reassessed it, ever so slowly your thinking changed, and as your thinking changed, so did the feelings. They’re not as burdensome anymore. You’re not as hurt. You’re not as devastated.

    From evangelical to Catholic

    Your thinking does that all the time. Not just from when you were 14 until now. It does it from last year. When I was in the evangelical world, I was pretty certain that the way they looked at things, their particular theology, was pretty solid, pretty correct. Well, as I started to look at things, church history, church logic, church thinking, church theology, my thinking changed. Yes, there’s a lot of beauty in the evangelical world, but I found the Catholic Church made more sense to me. My thinking changed. That happens all the time.

    If you’ve got a kid who’s 23 years old and flat out doesn’t want to hear anything about religion, and you’ve been beating yourself up, “Where’d I fail? How’d I do this? What happened?” You thought you were doing right. Maybe you weren’t doing right. Maybe you missed something. You should have prayed the rosary in Aramaic, not English. But over a couple of years you became more at peace with the situation because you recognized, one, that you did what you thought was best, however imperfect and human, and two, that you’re not responsible for how he thinks. You can’t be. He doesn’t want to hear anything you have to say. If he did, maybe you could try to reach him, but he doesn’t want to hear it. Not at all. Zero, zip, nada.

    And ultimately your feelings of self-defeat and self-deprecation started to fade because your thinking changed. Feelings do not occur in a vacuum. They are fueled or tapered by the way we look at things.


    Dr. Ray goes deeper on how our thinking shapes our faith and our peace in Thinking Like Jesus: The Psychology of a Faithful Disciple.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • Is an Algorithm Raising Your Kid?

    Is an Algorithm Raising Your Kid?

    Is an algorithm raising your kid? Dr. Ray explains how the algorithms on phones and computers feed kids more of whatever they look up, and why he says the only way to stop it is to delay access.

    “Is an algorithm raising your kid?”

    I heard a great line the other day: “Is an algorithm raising your kid?” I just became familiar with algorithms in the last couple of years. They are a piece of, if you want to use the word brilliant, maybe seductive is a better word, technology that says in so many words, “I’m going to see what you’re interested in.” The algorithm finds out whatever you look up on your phone or your computer, and says, “Oh, they’d like to see more of that.”

    So if your 13-year-old, who shouldn’t have a smartphone but does, looks up something regarding gender confusion or same-sex attraction, the algorithm says, “That’s what they’re interested in. We want to keep them interested, because we can sell more things and make more money.” And it starts sending many more things about gender confusion and same-sex attraction their way. It isn’t stuff that says, “Let’s measure this and see what it’s all about and think why you’re thinking this way.” No, no, no. It says, “This is what you should be heading toward.” Or if you’re a curious 14-year-old boy and you go into a site that has inappropriate material, what do you know? You can have some more of that. We’ll feed you a steady diet of it.

    “Most parents don’t know that”

    The interesting thing about technology is that most people can’t keep up with it. It moves ahead so fast that the average parent is unaware of what the algorithm does. It says, “If you show an interest in this, we will send you much more of this. It’ll pop up on your feed, on your phone, on your computer.” So in essence, the algorithm has a very potent hand in raising your kid. Most parents don’t know that. Over 50 percent of parents have absolutely no safety mechanisms on that phone or computer.

    So the algorithm says, “Let me have your kid. I’ll tell you how your kids are going to think. You, mom, you, dad, you think you’re doing a fine job of this.” And then one day they’re 19 years old and you wonder how they got to the point where they think so differently than the way we tried to raise them. Ask the algorithm. If you type in something that has to do with some sort of antagonism toward religion, what do you know? You get all kinds of stuff. They’ll slam religion. Why? Because I want to keep you watching. I want to keep you attached. I want to keep you addicted. I hate to use that word, but let me use it for now. And before you know it, I’ll have you shaped into thinking the way I want, “I” meaning the algorithm.

    “The only way to stop it”

    So the only way to stop the algorithm is not to let it have access to your kid. And the only way to do that is to have the strength to say, “This isn’t good.” The only way to stop it is to delay the access to it. Even if I’m only one in a hundred parents that does it now, realize the strength that takes. It should make you mad, actually, that they’re doing this to your kid.

    I remember reading a book about this, and they were quoting a lot of the guys who developed the technology to keep kids hooked. They said, “There’s no way I would let my kid get on this stuff, because I know what it can do. I designed it.” They were pretty upfront about it. So once more, the question: is the algorithm raising your kid?


    Dr. Ray gives parents more on holding the line in Raising Upright Kids in an Upside-Down World.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • Affection Sends a Powerful Message

    Affection Sends a Powerful Message

    How do I show my kids my strict standards come from love? Dr. Ray tells dads that regular physical affection, even when teens resist it, softens the standards they enforce, and he shares what he did with his own son.

    “Loads of love”

    It’s not unusual to have your kids look around and see that the culture’s standards are lower than yours. Your goals as a parent, the things you want to teach, the way you approach raising kids is different from the bulk of people out there. If you’re raising, you hope, citizens for God’s kingdom, then your approach is going to be sometimes rapidly out of sync with the rest of the culture. Your kids know this, and some of them don’t like it, some of them don’t like it a lot.

    So what do you do? How do you convince them that what you’re doing is not because you’re bucking for the Tyrant Parent of the Decade Award, but because you love them desperately? I want to speak a little to the dads about this. It comes more easily to moms, I believe, but it’s very important, and more so when it comes from dads. How do you express to those kids on a regular basis that you are motivated by loads of love, and not by “I’m the boss, kid, my way or the highway, punk”?

    Affection sends a powerful message

    There are many ways, but I look back on my own fatherhood and I realize how very important this is: affection. Physical touch, hugs, kisses, “love you.” Moms do it a lot, and maybe as a group they do it more than dads. I am so convinced of the power of that to get across the message that my standards are different from the culture’s, but it’s because I love you so very much.

    It gets harder when they move into their teens, because the teen rules are: don’t embarrass me out in public, don’t touch me, don’t look at me, don’t say anything. I’ll just walk behind you by about 50 yards, and don’t turn around and look like you know me. We have allowed the kids to dictate how much affection we’re allowed to show them, especially out in public. One of the things that was critical for me as a dad was that I did not allow my children to decide when, where and how much I would show them affection. Not going to happen.

    “Try not to stink the joint out”

    My youngest son, Pete, went to St. Thomas Aquinas High School in Louisville, Ohio. His sophomore year he played basketball. He was 16. Before the home games I’d perch myself up in the fourth or fifth row of the bleachers and watch the kids horse around down there on the gym floor, guys doing what guys do, snapping each other with towels. I’d wait for an appropriate moment, and then I’d go down to Petey, grab him, hug him, and kiss him on the neck, on the cheek. And as a psychologist, I’ve realized it’s very important to be affirming and positive before a game like that. So I would always say, “Pete, try not to stink the joint out.” He would laugh.

    Afterwards I said, “Pete, I’ll bother you when I do that.” He said, “Would it make any difference, Dad?” I said, “No, it wouldn’t.” And then he told me later that a couple of his teammates came up to him and said, “I wish my dad would do that.”

    If you’re not an affectionate guy, nobody’s forcing you to not be affectionate. Maybe it doesn’t feel at ease, but it will feel at ease the more you do it. It sends such a powerful message to the kids: you’ve got to understand, son or daughter, how very much I love you and what you mean to me in my life. And that softens the standards you’re trying to get across and the way you’re enforcing things. They’ve got a smartphone and they’re 15 and they’re thinking, “How did I get stuck with this Neanderthal?” But it’s hard for them to deny all the affection coming their way. That’s hard to ignore.

    To this day, my son, he’s in his 20s, I hug him and kiss him almost every time I see him. And I’m Italian, so we hug and kiss. Message to the dads: it’s wonderful to have high standards. It’s wonderful to walk counter-culturally. It is. You should have an easier time of it if they know how much you love them, and they’ll know how much you love them by how much you show it.


    Dr. Ray offers more on parenting against the grain in Raising Upright Kids in an Upside-Down World.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • The Myth of the Middle Child Syndrome

    The Myth of the Middle Child Syndrome

    Is middle child syndrome real? Dr. Ray looks at the research on birth order, explains why he thinks temperament matters far more, and walks through how his own kids kept moving in and out of the middle.

    “Middle child syndrome”

    National Middle Child Day, and we’ve got national days for everything, honors the in-between child in the family. It says larger families celebrate more than one middle child, too. I think that blows the whole theory of middle child syndrome out of the water. Many believe that birth order plays a pivotal role in the personalities of children. The first born is the leader, the youngest is the baby of the family, and therefore the middle child is kind of the lost child, in between. Well, if you look at the research, it doesn’t really support this nice little theory.

    Parents will say to me, “Oh, Dr. Ray, in my family that is the way it is. My middle child is the one who struggles the most, seeks the most attention, has the most self-image problems, doesn’t know where he fits in the family structure.” I think the explanation is more temperament. It’s the way he is wired innately. He would be that way if he were the oldest. “But Dr. Ray, isn’t that middle child syndrome?” Well, think about it. He has a one-in-three chance of being like that by temperament in that middle position, and one in three is plenty to keep the stereotype alive. They’d be that way if they were second oldest or fifth youngest. It doesn’t matter.

    “Don’t have an odd number of kids”

    I think middle child syndrome has gained momentum as families have gotten smaller. If you have three kids, that child was in the middle from when the baby was born, so let’s say he was four when the baby was born and his older sister was six. He had 10, 12, 15 years of being the middle child, so you could say that locks him into the middle child persona. Two children in a family is now much more the norm. So tell parents, if you’re worried about middle child syndrome, don’t have an odd number of kids. With four you can have an upper middle and a lower middle, but you really can’t have a middle.

    My guess was about 20 percent. It’s 15 percent: 15 percent of American families have three kids, just three. I wasn’t too far off. With five, it’s approximately 5 percent. So you have a middle child for years if you don’t have a big family.

    When we had three children, my daughter Hannah was the middle child. She didn’t stay middle child very long, maybe a year, year and a half. We adopted Sam, and Hannah moved up to upper middle. Then we adopted the twins a couple of years later, and Hannah was definitely second oldest of six. The twins shared the middle position, because there were six kids and they were three and four. But they were twins, so maybe they shared more middle than the typical middle. Then we got Pete, number seven, and I think that moved Sammy into the middle child position, number four: seven, six, five, Sammy four, middle, three, two, one. Then we went to eight and nine, James and Mary. Now Hannah is definitely the oldest next to Andrew, so she’s long since abandoned middle child. Did she have any residual middle child syndrome? Is there a chronic middle child syndrome left over from when she was middle child for about a year? Did she absorb the persona, or did she just shoot through the whole position? You see how complex it gets?

    Temperament beats birth order

    It really is a nice little cutesy theory, but it does not have much in the way of research support. The only place birth order seems to show anything is the oldest and the only group, a little more independent, a little more achieving, maybe as a group. And these are not automatic findings. We like to latch on to things that sound cutesy. Personality is very complex and very diverse.

    It’s fun, but here’s, I think, a little bit of the danger in it. It can predispose you to look for things that may not really be there, or may not be there in that intensity. “He’s got self-image problems. What do you expect? He’s a middle child.” “She acts up an awful lot, but that’s what I heard about middle children.” And you’re looking for the wrong explanation. Maybe she acts up because you’re not disciplining her well enough, because her temperament is a little more pushy. The oldest wasn’t that pushy. She is. Probably it’s the dynamic between the way you handle her and her temperament. Temperament is so much more powerful than birth order. Any parent of more than one kid knows how very different their personalities can be. And some of the most difficult kids fall in the middle: about a third of them if you have three kids, 20 percent if you have five, roughly 14 percent if you have seven, 11 percent if you have nine. They keep shifting around.

    I like where they say big families can have a number of middle children. We had four or five middle kids, but they didn’t stay there very long. They moved on or up. Fortunately, none of them moved down. Their personalities were shaped much more powerfully by how they were wired and by our parenting. So the middle child stuff is fun, but it really doesn’t have much impact. Let them have their National Middle Child Day.


    Dr. Ray talks about what a big family teaches in Taught by Ten.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • Non-Judgmental Language is Just Wrong

    Non-Judgmental Language is Just Wrong

    Why do therapists avoid saying a child’s behavior is wrong? Dr. Ray recalls the “non-judgmental” language he was trained to use and says it follows from leaving God out of the picture.

    “Inappropriate” instead of “wrong”

    I didn’t catch this when I was in grad school, because I was at one of those points in my life where I had one foot strongly planted in the psychological narrative about many things and one foot in my faith. I would have been more sensitive to this, except I wasn’t. How’s that for an explanation? The language we were told to use, the language that was the coin of the realm, was to be non-judgmental. You didn’t tell a child that punching his brother was wrong. That’s judgmental. You were to say that’s inappropriate or unacceptable. That was the language you were to use, not only with kids but with adults.

    So your 17-year-old daughter believes that you leaving your wife and her four siblings is just unacceptable, inappropriate, a bad choice, a mistake. You always wanted to go to confession: “Bless me, Father, mistakes were made.” You couldn’t use “wrong.” You couldn’t use “bad.” Those were such judgmental words. It’s like kicking a puppy. Unacceptable? I think it’s pretty bad, actually. And what if you’re in Boston and you’re rooting for the New York Yankees? That’s really bad. That’s not just inappropriate. “Bless me, Father, for I have made some inappropriate choices.”

    Why the language changed

    Part of the reason that language gained prominence was that we didn’t give much acknowledgment to God. He was sort of quietly shunted off to the side. He really didn’t have a part in our therapy. We recognized that some of our unenlightened clients might still believe in God, might still guide their lives by his suggestions. That is, not his commandments. That’s kind of overbearing. His options, the Ten Options. So we didn’t use words like “wrong.” Who’s to say what wrong is?

    Furthermore, with the self-esteem movement gaining momentum, if you say someone’s behavior is wrong or bad, you’re kind of digging up their self-esteem. If you say their behavior is inappropriate, that certainly takes away the stinger of doing something wrong to another person. But now, the ice pick in your sister’s arm: poor choice, unacceptable. Listen to young parents talk to their preschool children. I guarantee you, on a ratio of about 10 to one, you will hear “unacceptable,” “inappropriate,” “bad choices,” before you hear “wrong.” “What you did was very, very wrong” just stings of judgmentalism, doesn’t it?

    “If there is no God, you can’t say it’s wrong”

    You’ve got to figure it this way. If there is no God, and the mental health professions by and large tend to drift toward either no God, or they reconstruct him in a more psychologically acceptable image, then you really can’t say that something is wrong. How do you say it’s wrong? You say it’s socially unacceptable by current standards, or by current agreed-upon legalities or societal opinions. It just goes against the reigning psychological conduct standards, I guess.

    Leaving your wife and kids is wrong. Why is that? “Because… why? I don’t think it’s wrong. I’m unhappy, I’m miserable, I found somebody better. How could that be wrong? I want to be happy.” You can’t say that’s wrong. If there’s no God, the guy’s got a point. He really does. It’s pretty much a societal standard. “Yeah, I made a commitment, sort of, at one time, but so what?” “It’s wrong to break a commitment.” No, you can’t say that. Says who? When he made the commitment he wasn’t thinking ahead. He didn’t think he’d meet somebody else. He didn’t think his wife would be so difficult to live with. You can’t say it’s wrong. It’s maybe going to have unexpected consequences.

    Without God, most behavior is unacceptable or inappropriate if it’s negative. But if there is a God, you can probably still use “wrong” and “bad,” and those are good words. Those are acceptable words.


    Dr. Ray looks at how psychology looks different when you take God seriously in Jesus, The Master Psychologist: Listen to Him.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • Acting sorry is easier than saying, “I’m sorry.”

    Acting sorry is easier than saying, “I’m sorry.”

    Why is it so hard to say “I’m sorry”? Dr. Ray says many people find it easier to act nice than to apologize, and he tells how a florist figured out his flowers.

    “It is easier to talk nice than to do nice”

    Most of the time when we want to sound charitable or kind or nice, we talk nice. “Hey, I saw your yard there, and those oak trees nearby just clog up your flower beds. That looks like a real labor. Give me a call, I’ll get over there and help you out. Let me know.” “How long has it been since we’ve gotten together for lunch? Two, three years, right? Oh boy, one thing leads to another. Give me a call or I’ll give you a call, and we’ll have some lunch and catch up on things.” That’s nice stuff. I’m going to help him out with his leaves, and reconnect socially. It’s easy to talk that way. My intent is to be nice, be sociable, be kind.

    And then, three days later, the phone rings, and it’s the guy with the leaves. Thank heavens for caller ID. I wonder how many times I’m going to be able to duck his phone call. I just don’t have the time to get over there. It’s been six weeks since I said I’d call him for lunch, and he’s probably forgotten about it by now. It is easier to talk nice than to do nice, and forgive me for using the word nice, such a fluffy word, but it suits our purposes right now.

    Acting sorry versus saying sorry

    There’s one area that seems to be reversed, and that is apologies. For many people it is easier to act nice than to say “I’m sorry.” Acting sorry comes more naturally than saying “I’m sorry.” “I’m more complimentary now, or toned down, or calmer. I’m going to show you that I want to move on from what happened yesterday in our argument. Maybe I should apologize, but it’s too hard to apologize. So I’m going to be a much nicer person the next few days to show you that I’m past it, and let’s just move forward.”

    I went to a florist and said I’d like a rose and a carnation, trying to be really cool, because I read those books, trying to be sensitive. He said roses are for love and a carnation is for friendship, or whatever that means. And she said, “What did you do?” “What do you mean?” “When guys come in here and order flowers and it’s not a special occasion or a birthday, they’re usually saying I’m sorry.” “Well, that might be other guys, but not me and my wife. We have a very easygoing, transparent type relationship.” I’ll just have the flowers there. It’s not like you could prove it wrong.

    I got home like a little kid with the flowers behind my back. Little seven-year-olds go into the neighboring field and pick a bunch of stinkweeds and bring them home in a bouquet behind their backs, and moms are supposed to go, “Oh, isn’t that precious,” and then you can’t wait till the kid goes to sleep so you throw them out. So I had it behind my back. I said, “Honey,” and she came in, and I put the flowers out right there. And she said, “What did you do?” And I said, “Did you ever work for a florist?”

    Say it, then do it

    It’s easy to act as though you’re apologetic. It’s a lot harder to say the words. The best situation is to do both: say “I’m sorry,” and then put a little more effort into acting better. If you just act better, I suppose you’re counting on time to smooth everything over. “It’s been three days and I’ve been pretty nice the last three days. I emptied the dishwasher, gave a couple of extra kisses before I left. I guess that’s kind of a nonverbal ‘I’m sorry,’ isn’t it?” Sorry seems to be the one area where it is easier to act better than to say better.


    Dr. Ray covers repairing everyday friction in How to Get Along with Almost Everybody.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • Spiritual, but not Religious – Means Agnostic

    Spiritual, but not Religious – Means Agnostic

    What does “spiritual but not religious” really mean? Dr. Ray explains why he thinks the phrase sounds enlightened but is closer to agnosticism, and who ends up setting the terms.

    “I’m spiritual but not religious”

    Have you noticed that folks like to say things that sound enlightened and smart? But if you spent any amount of time thinking about them or analyzing them, they really are incredibly shallow and perhaps just flat out dumb. One of those, and I’m sure every single person listening has heard someone say it, is “I’m spiritual but not religious.” Maybe you’ve said it yourself at one point in your life. Hopefully you’re not still saying it.

    My first response to that is, what in the heck does that mean? You’ve got to define spiritual and you’ve got to define religious. So that’s the first problem: usually they’re self-defined. If anybody says that to you, you could start the conversation by asking, “What do you mean by spiritual?” And then, “What do you mean by religious?”

    When somebody says, “I’m spiritual not religious,” I think what they think they’re saying is, “I am not irreligious. I am not an atheist. I am closer to God, if he’s part of their spirituality, and a lot of times he isn’t, than this rote religion type stuff.” So while they mean to imply that they have some more mature kind of spiritual connection to whatever, actually it’s the opposite. They are closer to being agnostic.

    “I worship me”

    Dr. Ray, what are you talking about? Let me explain, Lucy. I’m spiritual. Spiritual to what? For many it just means, “Well, I believe there’s a higher power. There’s a higher something out there looking over us. This isn’t all there is.” Some of them may even say, “Yeah, I believe that something else is God.” Maybe not the God of the Bible, but the God. Given all that, they feel like they’ve got some kind of connection. They’re not just muddling along, paying no attention to anything other than what is here and now.

    Sometimes they will say, “I’m spiritual in the sense that I want a connection to something bigger than myself.” I was watching a sitcom once and she was trying to get her husband to go to church. He didn’t want to go, so he asked her, “Why do you go?” And she said, and I think this captures a vague spirituality, “Well, I just want to think there’s something bigger than ourselves, something more.” All right, that may be a tiny baby step toward God, but it’s meaningless, because what “I’m spiritual” ultimately means is I worship me.

    That’s not what it means, Dr. Ray? Of course it does. I define it. I say what’s spiritual. If I have a connection with the universe, or let’s take it all the way out: I like to pray, I believe there is a God, I even believe that Jesus is God. Take it all the way out and somebody calls that spiritual, and then they say, “But I want no part of religion.”

    Religion without any rules

    Now, here’s the other cliche. What do you mean by religion? Typically they mean rules, regulations, laws, responsibilities, and they want no part of that. All right, then who decides? Obviously you do. If you don’t want any part of what has been traditionally recognized as God in the flesh through Christ, or even if you’re not a Christian, the God who created the universe, if you don’t want any part of his recommendations for moral living, you just know that’s religion. And what do you follow? You follow you. In irony, you’re very religious. Why would I say that? Because you set the terms. If you set the terms on what spirituality is and what is not religious, then you’re 100% following them, because they’re yours. Why wouldn’t you?

    I think “I’m spiritual but not religious” is a way of saying, “Well, I don’t think this is all there is, but I still want to live the way I want to live. I still want to do it my way,” in the words of the song. So it’s a nice, enlightened-sounding out. I can decide which of these spiritual commitments I want to follow. I can be spiritual and have sex before marriage. I can be spiritual and believe that it’s OK to kill a baby in a womb. I can be spiritual and not pray but once a month and a half, if life throws something in my way and I better cry out to some being that’s up there somewhere in my spirituality. Yeah, I can do that. That’s all spiritual, isn’t it? Spiritual, meaningless. If it’s not attached to anything, it’s attached to me, the worship of the self.

    “Well, I just don’t buy these religions who stand between me and Jesus.” But what if Jesus said, “Here is how you connect with me. Here is how you follow me”? I can just imagine me saying to my wife, “Honey, I got to tell you, I am spiritually married to you, but I don’t really want any responsibilities, any kind of commitment, any kind of moral guidelines to this marriage. Just be satisfied that our marriage is spiritual.” How far would that go? Or with anybody: “Don’t ask me to do anything for you, but just know that I feel spiritual toward you. I feel connected. Well, if you’re sick and in the hospital, don’t ask me to visit you, because that’s kind of like a demand. That’s kind of like a responsibility, and that’s like a religious thing.”

    “I’m spiritual, but not religious.” That is one of the dumbest things that somebody can say. And the irony is it sounds so smart, it sounds so enlightened. They haven’t defined spiritual and they haven’t defined religious. And what’s worse is they’ve made religion into something that is not a beautiful way to connect with God and Jesus Christ.


    Dr. Ray tackles the hard questions about living the faith in everyday life in Family Faith Under Fire.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • The Teenager Stereotype

    The Teenager Stereotype

    Is the difficult teenager just a normal stage? Dr. Ray says he doesn’t believe surliness is automatic in the teen years, and tells why he thinks the stereotype is more cultural than developmental.

    “Well, that’s teenagers”

    My producer and I last week were talking about teenagers, because his daughter is 13. He said she’s a doll, she’s just a very easy kind of kid to raise. But he was talking to someone he knew whose teen was pretty surly and disrespectful. And the comment given to that parent was, “Well, that’s teenagers. That’s who they are. You’ve kind of got to weather it.” Or the room is a pigsty, so you just close the door. Of course, I don’t really know what a pigsty is. I’ve never really seen one. One comedian said his mother was an expert on pigsties. She would say, “This is the worst pigsty I have ever seen,” which raises the question, how many pigsties have you seen?

    The experts will tell you, and I’ve not done an official survey, but informally I would bet the majority would say, “Oh, let it go. It’s his domain. Shut the door.” Animals can gnaw through wood, but it’s your house. It may be the natural dishevelment of possessions of teenagers, but is it good?

    I don’t believe that “teenager just is.” In other words, that they get more argumentative or more surly about things, more difficult in their thinking. I don’t believe that is the natural progression. First of all, “teenager” is a relatively new term. For the most part, you just sort of grew up, and in many places in the history of the world, you didn’t even know your age. I remember we were talking to a missionary priest from one of the African countries, and I said, “Father, how old are you?” “I’m 72.” He looked like he was about 35. I said, “Father, you’re 72? Do you know when your birthday is?” “No, we don’t keep track of that.” So the whole idea of a certain persona unique to the teen years is a relatively new thing.

    More cultural than developmental

    I personally believe, after years of being in this business, that the stereotype of the more difficult teenager is not as much developmental as it is cultural. You parents who have younger kids, you hear these things: “Oh, enjoy them now. Those teenage years are right around the corner. My nine-year-old daughter loved me until she became 12.” And they scare you. Look out, here it comes. Nothing you’re going to do about it. They’re just going to act like this.

    Where I am sitting right now in this studio at Domino’s Farms, I don’t know how far back I would have to go to say this was a farm field or a meadow or a woods. But let’s just say it was a farm 150 years ago. Do you suppose that the farmer, when his boy turned 14, would be bemoaning to his friends, “Well, my son is 14. He’s one of them teenagers. He used to be real helpful, but now I can’t get nothing out of him. It’s hard to get him up in the morning. My other buddies are telling me the same thing. I’m just waiting until he gets to be 19 or 20 and decides he can be a little more help around here”? I don’t think so. I think that farmer was ecstatic that that boy was 14, because he was high energy, indefatigable, and could give him some real help around the place.

    I think one of the reasons that kids in their teens become a little more resistant to parents’ rules or limits or structure is they look around. Especially if you have standards and supervision that are different from the norm, they look around and they compare. They get resentful or upset or argumentative: “Why can’t I have that? Why can’t I do that? I’m 15. I should be able to do that. Everybody I know can do that.” And that breeds a sort of attitude. We use that word a lot with teens, don’t we? “Oh, she’s just got that attitude.” The word attitude has become pejorative, because if her attitude was, “Hello, Mother, how might I help you today?” you wouldn’t call it attitude, but that’s an attitude, just a good one. So we use the word attitude to describe their words, surliness, argumentativeness, whatever kind of demeanor. I just don’t believe that’s automatic with the adolescent years.

    “Oh, Dr. Ray, come on. Our hormones are kicking in. Boys get feistier. Girls may get a little more emotional and moody.” That is true. The body’s changed. I got that part. I just can’t fathom that it accounts for all of it.

    “Our children would never talk like that”

    I was in Cleveland once, checking in at a hotel. The clerk was a girl who, I found out, was from Nigeria. I asked her, “Are you here permanently?” She said, “No, I’m just here for school.” I asked, “What strikes you right away about our culture and your culture in Nigeria?” She didn’t hesitate. She said, “Your children.” What do you mean? “Our children would never be able to talk like that to their parents. Never. It wouldn’t be tolerated at all. It would be stopped.” I didn’t go into details on how they stopped it. She noticed it right away. Didn’t they have teenagers over there? Wasn’t adolescence and hormonal change happening over there? Now, again, this is just anecdotal. This is her perception, and I didn’t know what part of Nigeria she was from.

    My wife and I had 10 teenagers. They’ve all passed through teenagerhood, and at one time we had seven of them at the same time. Did we get a little more pushiness from the kids, getting to be more of what they want? Yeah, we did. But I’ve got to say, we did not have this idea of, “Man, I can’t wait till this kid grows up and gets through this phase.” I think part of it for us is we can tolerate it, but we don’t allow it. And our standards were probably different. We homeschooled, so right away standards are going to be different in a lot of respects from their general educated peer group.

    I guess the message of all this is, don’t be so quick to chalk it up to standard adolescence or teenagerhood that you have to wait to pass. Recognize you can address it, you can deal with it. And yes, you may get a little more of it, but it doesn’t have to characterize those years. Natural teen years, I’ll tell you what, they’re zestful, they’re bubbly, they’re fun, they’re energetic. At least that’s what it used to be before social media and the culture started telling them they’ve got to be dissatisfied and depressed. The natural persona of teens, would you like to have a lot of that energy back? That’s what it is. Don’t let anybody talk you into this: “Oh, that’s just the way they are. That’s how mine talks to me too. That’s just who they are.” No, it’s not just who they are.


    Dr. Ray goes deeper on raising teens with good discipline in Standing Strong: Good Discipline Makes Great Teens.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • The Payoff of Complaining

    The Payoff of Complaining

    Why do people complain so much? Dr. Ray looks at the internal and external payoffs of complaining, why chronic complainers push people away, and what complaining says about gratitude.

    The payoffs of complaining

    In my most recent book, How to Get Along with Almost Everybody, there’s a chapter on something called conversation killers. Complaining is one of them. But there has to be some payoff for complaining, otherwise, no payoff, people wouldn’t do it. So there are internal and external payoffs.

    The old country song says, “You can feel bad if it makes you feel better.” Is there something about complaining that is internally rewarding? Is it a rehearsal of, “Life hasn’t been good to me”? Is it a rehearsal of, “I’m not getting my fair shake”? Is it a rehearsal of, “I’ve got to voice this because I’m feeling emotionally so distressed that I’ve got to give words to it”? Something is internally rewarding about complaining.

    Maybe, though, it’s easier to understand the external rewards. When you complain, especially to people who care a lot about you, their tolerance for listening is longer. They will listen to your complaints because they love you and they’re concerned about you and they care what’s happening in your life. When you complain to somebody who really doesn’t know you all that well, their tolerance is a lot less. Why would they want to listen to what’s going bad for you, especially if what’s going bad for them in their mind dwarfs what’s going bad for you? And we’ll get to that in a second. Some people, when you complain, will commiserate. They will pull alongside of you empathetically and talk about how bad that is or how sad that must make you or how frustrated you are by that. They’ll do something or say something that is considered affirming to you, shrink talk. So there’s a reward to that.

    Why chronic complainers push people away

    Chronic complainers push people away. We’ve had so many calls on this program, and I get it with my folks in the office, where they won’t pick up the phone with relatives or friends because they just don’t want to hear 29 minutes of complaining. Complaining is also particularly grating when it’s nothing but complaining. It’s not an attempt to solve any problem. Any advice given is usually batted away, ignored, or countered: “I can’t do that.” Why? “Because I have this problem and this problem you don’t understand.” So complaining is less tolerable when the person doing the complaining isn’t interested in any kind of resolution to their complaints.

    But here is, I think, a much more subtle maleffect of complaining. In many cases, you don’t know who you’re complaining to, and you don’t know their circumstances. If this is a close friend or a relative, you may know some things about their life, but not everything. I had a client many, many years ago who came to me dealing with grief over her little nine-year-old daughter passing away from leukemia. One of the things she said was a revelation to herself is that her tolerance for other people’s complaining after her daughter’s death dropped dramatically, particularly if they were complaining about their kids. If she didn’t share with them the details, or even the death of her daughter, they had no idea. So they were complaining away to a woman who so desperately wanted to have her daughter back.

    A friend of mine told me that he went to a job interview, and a fellow was leaning back in his chair, staring out the window with his back to my friend. My friend walked in and the fellow said, “Have you ever had a really bad day?” That was an odd way to start an interview, my friend thought. He said, “Well, I guess I have. A lot of people have had bad days.” And the fellow turned and said, “You know, I thought that I had a lot of really bad days until I had a really bad day.” He turned around and his face was completely disfigured. He had been either trapped in a fire or something exploded, and he was nothing but scar tissue as they attempted to put his face back together. Of course, it was a face that got a lot of stares. It was a face that maybe scared little kids. And he complained a lot less about the stuff of complaining.

    Complaining and weak gratitude

    Complaining also is a sign of weak gratitude. Why am I going to focus on telling you all about how I have a problem with my big toe when in fact I can walk, or I have shoes? I saw a young man today at the dealership, probably somewhere in his mid-twenties. He walked in with a prosthesis on his left leg. It was a more modern one, not the old type, with a spring. He walked with a noticeable wobble, because of course you can’t replace a natural limb. I looked at that young man and thought, in all likelihood, given his age, he was in the military. Probably an IED. And I’m sitting there doing some writing with two good legs, and I’m thinking, yeah, okay, so I’ve got some problems in my knee here. I bet that guy wished he had problems in his knee.

    There’s got to be a payoff to complaining, both internally and externally. The key is to get rid of the payoff. To get rid of the payoff, you’re likely to complain less.


    Dr. Ray covers conversation killers like this one in How to Get Along with Almost Everybody.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • The Law of Lecturing

    The Law of Lecturing

    Why do lectures stop working on kids? Dr. Ray jokes about the parental lecture, explains why we give them, and says the longer the lecture, the less it is heard.

    Why parents lecture

    A staple of parenthood is the parent’s lecture, especially when the kids pull some stunt or do something that absolutely collides with the character you’ve been trying to teach. We feel desperate, and when we get desperate, we lecture.

    To us, a lecture really isn’t a lecture until it hits maybe 30,000 or 40,000 words. To kids, a lecture is anything that begins with “I want to talk to you” or “When I was your age” or “What were you thinking?” or “Listen up.” A compound sentence, that’s a lecture. Two independent clauses linked together by “and” or “but,” that’s a lecture. To them anyway.

    Why do we lecture? We think that given enough words, there’s going to be more persuasion. Somehow, some way, we will move through a chain of reasoning or cite other evidence that, as we proceed through the lecture, is going to essentially make a case. Maybe our first 800 words didn’t do anything, but who knows, 801 through 4,000 just might. We cling to the hope that we’re going to get through. I’m not saying we don’t. I would think that we would, approximately 1.62% of the time, but there’s always the hope, springing eternal.

    My mother’s lectures

    My mom was wonderful at lectures. “Raymond Nicholas Guarendi. How many times are you going to make me call you in here, Buster? You know, buddy boy, you seem to think I talk just to hear myself talk. You seem to think I like the sound of my own voice. I’m going to tell you something, you better listen and you better listen good, because I’m not going to say it again. I was not put on this earth to serve you. There are five other people in this house. You think we’re going to involve our schedule around yours? You mark my word, there are going to be some changes around here, because I am sick and I am tired. I have just about had you up to here. You don’t realize how good you’ve got it, but you’re going to find out something, because I’m going to tell you something else. You look at me when I talk to you. Don’t you look at me like that.”

    I didn’t really move. I mean, she wasn’t mad enough yet. My mother’s philosophy was, if the first 30,000 didn’t get you anywhere, double it. “You think you’ve got it tough? I am going to tell you what tough is. When I was a little girl, I used to walk 18 miles uphill both ways to school in a foot of nuclear waste with no shoes. We had one pair that glowed for 14 brothers and sisters. My turn only came around every two weeks, and I always gave my turn away. That’s the kind of girl I was. I got up at five o’clock in the morning, two hours before we were even allowed to go to bed, split a cornflake for breakfast with six brothers, carried the school on my back, did their homework along the way. You want to know something? I was grateful for what little I had.” What’d you have, Mom? “Nothing. Weren’t you listening? But we were happy children.”

    The law of diminishing returns

    The temptation to lecture is ever present. We just want to get through. We want to explain to them why we are parenting the way we’re parenting, why we think the way we think, why we don’t let them do what they want to do, why we do let them do what they don’t want to do. We just have to get through to them, to understand.

    You know the irony? As most kids get older, I’m talking seven, eight, nine, they do understand. At some primitive level, they do. They just don’t agree. That’s the difference. A client will be in my office with a 14-year-old, and I’ll say to the kid, “Would you please tell your mother why she has that rule?” And this kid says it better than I could say it. I get the smelling salts out, I revive mother, and I say, “What do you think of that?” She says, “Well, I never thought she understood it.” I say, “She always understood it, Mom.” She didn’t agree. There’s the difference.

    If you want to lecture, go ahead, but keep in mind, you get past a certain point where you’re not only getting no results, you’re probably regressing. Law of diminishing returns: the more you talk, the less you get listened to. Make your case, make it clear, ask if they have any questions, and then probably let it go, because after a while, you know what you sound like? Charlie Brown, when he’s holding up the phone, and you hear, “Want, want, want, want, want.” Or, and this is something I’ve noticed people do, they lecture their dogs. Did you ever notice that? “Now you get in here right now. What did you do? You see what you did in here? Are you allowed to do that in here? No, you’re not. And what happened the last time you…” And you know what the dog hears? “Blah, blah, blah, blah, Max, blah, blah, blah, Max.” Let the dogs give us a lesson. So if you want to lecture, go ahead, but keep in mind, the longer the lecture, probably the less it’s heard.


    Dr. Ray goes deeper on this in Discipline That Lasts a Lifetime.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • Pick Your Battles!

    Pick Your Battles!

    Is “pick your battles” good parenting advice? Dr. Ray says it is fine for kid junk but a problem when it means letting disrespect go, and uses the broken window theory to explain why.

    What the experts say

    Never in human history has raising children been taken over by experts like it has in the last 40, 50, 60 years. The experts conveyed to parents that there are certain psychologically correct ways to raise children. And you parents, not being professionals, how do you know if you’re doing the right thing? I get that all the time from parents. Am I doing the right thing? Am I talking the right way? Am I saying the right things? Experts have all kinds of ideas and notions, almost as many as there are experts, and they have phrases to summarize their notions. There are a lot of them, but I’ll just pick one for this audio blog. “Pick your battles!”

    In other words, there are certain things as a parent that I assume they mean you should stand firm on, although they might think you should stand weak on things that you think you should stand firm on, because many experts are not religious and therefore don’t have your worldview. They say, in picking your battles, as a parent let some things go and then intervene and teach, or maybe, as a last resort, discipline. I have a real problem with “pick your battles.”

    Kid junk

    You can interpret it two ways. The first way I pretty much agree with. If the child is being a kid, he’s not doing anything wrong. He’s watching TV and he’s standing on his head. You may think to yourself, “What are you doing? Why are you standing on your head?” But he’s just being a kid. He doesn’t hurt anything. My son used to stand on his head in the crib when he was about two until he fell over and fell asleep. Or you send him to bed and he’s in bed but he’s just kind of singing to himself. He’s not getting out of bed. He’s not saying he has to go to the potty 26 times. He’s just kind of in bed singing. Is that a battle?

    I think a nice way to separate it out is kid junk, the stuff of kidhood, which isn’t irresponsible or immoral or hurtful to anybody else. Let it go. A lot of times we’re tempted as parents to pick on something, comment, nag about something that’s not wrong. There’s nothing bad about it. We just don’t like it. It irritates us. He’s outside running in circles. “Hey, settle down. Settle down. Why are you just running?”

    Where the experts trip up parents

    But here’s where I think the experts trip up parents. I’ll use a teenage example. Teens are notorious for rolling their eyes at parents, and that’s just viewed as standard teenhood. It’s what they do. They’ll grow out of it. That kind of demeaning disdain is, “Well, that’s standard adolescence. Let it go. Pick your battles. He’s not throwing a brick at you. He’s not cussing at you. He’s not screaming at you. He’s not being loudly disrespectful. He’s just rolling his eyes. Come on. Pick your battles.” That’s where I really have a hard time with experts. Basically, they say if it gets really serious in your eyes, then you do something about it. But the little stuff of disrespect, or the little stuff of mistreating a sibling, or the little stuff of not cleaning their room? “Pick your battles. Let the room go. It’s not a big deal. Who are you to ask that they keep their room clean?” I think that dramatically undercuts parents’ decision-making authority.

    We didn’t allow rolling eyes in our house at all. That’s disdainful. That’s nasty. That’s nonverbal disrespect. That’s basically a slap on the right cheek. When our Lord said, “Turn the other cheek,” he wasn’t talking about parents saying, “Well, okay, you can be disrespectful to me, kid. I’ll just turn the other cheek.” No, our role is to teach.

    I’ll draw a parallel. There was something called the broken window theory of law enforcement. This was tried, I believe, in New York City. For a while, the approach was, “Let’s just tackle the big stuff. Let’s just go after the larger rule-breaking offenses. The smaller stuff, couches on the curb that are set on fire, or broken windows in abandoned buildings, let it go. Pick your battles.” What they found was that translated into more rule-breaking of all kinds. When they took a zero tolerance toward the small stuff, “You’re going to get in trouble for setting a couch on fire. You’re going to get in trouble for breaking a window,” they found that the big stuff declined. Why? The theory was it conveyed an impression: someone is in charge. When all this little stuff, relatively speaking, but it’s still law-breaking, still vandalism, was allowed to go, it created an overall impression that there’s deterioration, nobody’s really in charge.

    I draw a parallel to parenthood. It creates an overall impression. The kid can roll his eyes at you, and you let it go. Is he going to stop there? “I rolled my eyes at you, but the next thing out of my mouth is going to be snotty.” “Pick your battles” is not good advice if you’re trying to teach virtue. It’s good advice if you’re letting a kid be a kid. Childhood stuff. It’s not hurting anyone, it’s not irresponsible, it’s not immoral. Just kid junk. There’s a lot of that. Pick your battles. Well, let me put it to you this way: that’s a phrase that I’m going to pick my battle about.


    Dr. Ray explains how to teach virtue and keep parental authority in Discipline That Lasts a Lifetime.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.