Blog

  • Benign Underparenting is Good

    Benign Underparenting is Good

    Is it actually good to parent your kids a little less? Dr. Ray reads from an article on “mindful underparenting,” looks at what parents say they want most for their children, and adds a story about boredom.

    “I just want them to be happy”

    This was sent to me by Janet Clark. Some of you might know she has been, many, many times, especially in the northeastern Ohio area, my role-play co-actress in the different things we do on “Living Right with Dr. Ray.” We usually have an informal role play to try to make some point about life or living.

    Let me preface this. I was watching a sitcom once, and the parent, when talking to the spouse about her desire for her kids, said, “I want them to be happy. I just want them to be happy.” At the time, of course, I can’t shut my mouth. I make these comments, which probably drives my wife crazy. I’ve got to make psychological comments. I said, “Happy. So that’s the priority here, happy.” And I thought to myself, I wonder, if I pay attention, how many of the programs we watch on TV, if the topic comes up, have a parent saying, “I just want my kids to be happy.”

    Well, I have been confirmed, well, not sacramentally, in my observation. A recent Pew Center study reports that parents want above all else for their children financial independence and a satisfying job. Okay, that’s one and two. Graduating from college was a distant third. Getting married and having children of their own, according to this article, and I like the way they said this, pulled up the rear. Being moral, finding meaning in life, or practicing a religion did not appear on the list of priorities.

    How is this relevant? Well, when you compare it to other survey data, which basically says that our young people, the Gen Z years and maybe the Millennials, have the highest recorded rates of anxiety and depression of any group surveyed, the article says: with such external and materialistic aspirations for their children, it is not surprising, though it’s a sad irony, that these same parents reported they are most worried about their children’s mental health. These same parents want financial independence and a satisfying job first and foremost for their kids, with getting married way, way, way down, and being moral, finding meaning in life, religion, not even showing up on the radar.

    “Parents should ignore their children more often”

    This is an interesting suggestion by a psychologist named Darby Saxbe. I said “the guy,” but, sorry about that, Darby is female. Boy, this is really bad for the gentle parenting folk. Quote: “Parents should ignore their children more often.” Now, this makes for an ear-catching phrase, but here’s what she means. Not so much that the kids should be ignored, as that they be de-centered. She argues that today’s frantic, child-centered, helicopter parenting is, quote, “based on assumptions about what our children need to thrive that are not supported by evidence from most of human history until the last few decades.” Parents practiced what she calls “mindful underparenting.”

    Now, this allows kids to, quote, “spend lots of time with their parents but not usually as the parents’ primary focus, sometimes bored, sometimes engaged.” I’m quoting her now. These kids spend much of their time observing adults doing adult things. Now, this is a shocker, and I can see this. She says, quote, “Your average daycare is probably closer to the average historical childhood experience than today’s overstimulated boy or girl at the center of attention.” Whoo.

    Let’s see if there’s anything else she says. They go on to talk about how kids observe us, and we are still the greatest influence. It says here, “The good news is that among all possible influences, parents exert far and away the greatest influence on their children’s religious outcomes.” Well, let me qualify that. If they so intentionally do, they can exert the greatest possible influence. All right, there you go. There’s a lot more she says, but let’s leave it at that.

    “Children need boring time”

    By the way, just as a P.S. here, my second book was called “Back to the Family,” and we interviewed strong families in all 50 states. We were talking about spending time with your kids, and one mother observed, she said, “Children need boring time. They need to have time just to look at stuff, not the computer screen, outside stuff, curiosity stuff. They need time.”

    One time I said this to a priest from Africa. We were talking about raising kids, and I said, “A lot of parents hear from their children, ‘I’m bored.’” He looked at me, puzzled. He said, “What is that word?” I said, “Bored.” He says, “Yes?” I said, “Well, it means kind of like you don’t really have anything to do.” And then he said, “How could you not have anything to do?” They did not have a word in his language, in his tribal language, for “boring.” Interesting, isn’t it?


    On the question of what parents should put first, Dr. Ray’s book Raising Upright Kids in an Upside-Down World picks it up.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • The most common and wrong adjective leveled at children…

    The most common and wrong adjective leveled at children…

    Is my child really strong-willed? Dr. Ray explains why he thinks “strong-willed” is the most overused and misleading label parents put on kids. He covers why it exploded and what he suggests a parent do first if they are convinced they have one.

    “The most common adjective leveled at children”

    I have come to the conclusion that the most common adjective leveled at children, pretty much of all ages, is also a very misleading one. It’s an unfair one, in most cases. What word am I alluding to? Strong-willed.

    Years ago, James Dobson, psychologist for Focus on the Family, wrote the book The Strong-Willed Child. I think it was in the 80s, maybe even the 70s. Of course, most people think they have at least one strong-willed child.

    Now, why do I think that adjective is so misleading, so heavily overused? And by the way, it has variants. He is so oppositional. She has a mind of her own. Very high maintenance. Challenging child, very challenging child. Seven going on 17. We have a difficult child, according to our pediatrician. Difficult child, folks, is redundant.

    So why did these words explode? My mother-in-law had five children, one of them my wife. She said to my wife one time, “I don’t remember talking with other parents when I was raising the kids about how difficult and challenging and strong-willed the kids were.” And I said, “Ma, I think that’s a new phenomenon.”

    Why the label exploded

    Let me give you a couple of reasons. One is the onslaught of experts giving you all their theories and notions about how you are to talk to children and be gentle with children and reason with children and use I-messages and not U-messages and use sticker systems and set up win-win scenarios. When you try doing these things, they may work for a small percentage of kids. I’m not saying they don’t, but they don’t work for the majority of kids at all.

    And it looks like the kids are unusually difficult. If this stuff isn’t working, you obviously don’t have a normal child. You’ve got somebody a little more stubborn, a little more strong-willed, a little more challenging, a little more oppositional, a little mind of her own.

    I’m not saying you don’t be gentle with a kid, of course you do, but you have to have authority, calm, quiet, confident authority. And if you don’t, the kid’s going to be very difficult for you. There’s just no question about that. It is a direct relationship. He is going to be pushy, challenging, contrary, argumentative. Excuse me for saying “he,” but most behavioral problems are boys.

    Second, much of the time when parents come into my office, I ask them, “Do you think you have a strong-willed child?” Oh yes, very, the strongest will of all my children. My other children are not like this. What’s the school say? They don’t see any of this. He’s there six hours. That teacher doesn’t have a fraction of your authority. So how is it that the teacher gets cooperation, thinks he’s a delight, loves having him in class, and you think he’s strong-willed?

    Third, to quote G.K. Chesterton, fallen human nature, or sin nature, I forget what Chesterton called it, is the one doctrine of Christianity that has abundant empirical evidence. Abundant.

    “The strongest will of my kids was not stronger than his mother”

    So those are some explanations. There’s more. The biggest one is basically parents. I had ten children. I didn’t consider any of them strong-willed. Am I delusional? No, I think there’s a straightforward explanation. The strongest will of my kids was not stronger willed than his mother. That’s it.

    Yes, they varied in their strength of will. Of course they do. They vary in the way they challenge. They vary in the way they learn from experience. Some go to the corner twice, and that’s it. Others go to the corner 264 times and go, “Hey, wait a minute. So you’re saying if I do that, I’m going to go to the corner? Aha! I get it now.”

    Now, are there strong-willed children? Yes, but I haven’t seen many of them in my career. If you want me to put a percentage on it, under 1 percent. There are those who are just bound and determined, bent on resisting rules and limits no matter how good their parents are.

    But many of the parents who come into my office think they’re very good at disciplining, and this kid is just hell-bent on challenging them. As we talk over the hour or two or however long the sessions are, we find out there’s a lot they could be doing differently. Not because they’re bad people, but because they’ve been making some bad moves in handling this kid. That’s all. Then they tell me two, three, four weeks later, and I ask, “Do you think he’s still strong-willed?” Well, I’m not sure I’d use that word anymore.

    If you think you have a strong-willed kid, if you’re convinced of it, the first thing you do is size up your own parenting. You say, “Okay, wait a minute. I think I’m a good disciplinarian. I think I’m consistent. I think I follow through. I think I have standards.” Okay, I’m not going to argue with any of that. But typically, and maybe you need some help sorting through it, you can either come to a guy like me as a client, or you can pick up one of my parenting books that will explain all this and help you realize, “Wait a minute, there are things I could be doing differently, and then let’s see if he’s still so strong-willed.”


    For the discipline basics behind all this, Dr. Ray’s book Discipline That Lasts a Lifetime is a good place to start.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • He’s a Special Child

    He’s a Special Child

    Should I go easy on discipline because my child has been through a hard time? Dr. Ray describes the “He’s a Special Child” trap, where parents of kids hurt by life back off on limits. He explains why love and support are one thing and lowering the standard for behavior is another.

    A little guy with a hearing problem

    I consulted for several years to a number of Head Start programs. Basically I did evaluations and consulted with the teachers. I remember one year we had a little guy, about four, four and a half. He had significant hearing problems, to the point where it really affected his interaction with other kids. This little guy was an extreme behavior problem. He was uncooperative. He threw major league resistant fits. Very difficult.

    One interpretation, and I think this is one that would be glommed onto by someone looking for a lot of complicated psychological reasons, would be that he’s frustrated. The poor little guy can’t interact with people, so his emotions get the better of him and he reacts. I’m not ruling that out. That could be a part of it.

    But as I met with the parents, I found that they felt very guilty about life ripping him off, that he couldn’t hear normally. As a consequence they didn’t want to put limits on his conduct or discipline him, because they felt he was so frustrated by his deficiency in hearing that holding him accountable for some of the nasty stuff he was doing would be mean-spirited and unpleasant. So what you had was a little guy whose conduct was more of a handicap for him than his hearing handicap.

    “He’s a Special Child”

    My first book was titled You’re a Better Parent Than You Think. It sprang from my experience at a mental health center, where I quickly became the parenting go-to guy and saw an awful lot of parents. Good people! Insecure, second-guessing, irresolute, lacking authority, frustrated by their kids. A lot of it was because they didn’t allow themselves to have legitimate, fair, helpful, healthy authority. One of the chapters in the book was called “How to Talk Yourself Out of Authority.” One of the sections of that chapter was “He’s a Special Child.” Here’s how it works.

    You have a child, and it doesn’t have to be a six-year-old, it can be a fifteen-year-old, who you believe has been ripped off by life. One of the more common rip-offs is a divorce. The custodial parent feels very badly for the child because the mom or the dad is not a consistent part of their life anymore. Or you have a child on the autistic spectrum, with a developmental problem that makes it more difficult to interact appropriately with others. Or a child who’s developmentally delayed, who’s ten but functions like a seven-year-old overall. Anything that brings a child out of the realm of normal, unhindered development is a risk. A lot of parents say, “Life has not been fair to my child, therefore I have to understand what he’s dealing with, and therefore I have to be very loose in implementing any discipline, because of his overall frustration level and his struggle to deal with his handicap, whatever that might be.”

    In situations like that, I’m quick to counsel parents. On one hand, you do understand that this child may have his own special issues in learning responsibility, learning self-control, learning to treat people with respect, acting appropriately socially, because of his particular developmental, emotional, and sometimes transient issues. If a parent dies, I’ve had that a lot. I’ve seen some severe behavior problem kids in my office whose parent died when they were seven, eight, and nine, and the surviving parent, now that the kid’s 15, essentially stopped disciplining because they felt so terrible that this kid was hurting so badly about losing a mom or dad.

    I counsel them: it is one thing to give emotional support. More hugs, more kisses, more positives, more time. That is one thing. But you do not do a child any favors, any help, any good by saying, “Because life has been tough on you as I see it, I can’t add to it by expecting you to act appropriately or respectfully or socially right.” I’ve seen so many kids, because of that, become very difficult young adults. And it isn’t because of the original handicap or life struggle. It’s because the parents backed off in teaching and socializing and moralizing this child.

    Don’t do it. It’s one thing to be hurting because of your particular situation, but that is not a justification for being nasty or disrespectful or hurtful or mean-spirited to other people. They still have to be held accountable with loving discipline.

    “Ray, you big dummy!”

    When we adopted our twins, they were undisciplined. They were four years old and had not been disciplined well for the first four years of their lives, and the son especially was just out of control. I remember one time lying in bed and saying to my wife, “Honey, I don’t know. Maybe we ought to loosen up here with him.” And she said, very supportively and lovingly, “Ray, you big dummy!” Okay, she didn’t say that, but I could read it in her eyes.

    She said, “We can’t do that. We’ll give them more hugs, more kisses, tell them how much we love them, but it wouldn’t be fair to them to lower the standards for them that we don’t lower for the other kids.” And she was right. So they did get more discipline in the beginning because they just had so many things that were socially inappropriate and out of control. But with time, they settled in. It did take a while, but they did settle in.

    My wife is exactly right. She said, “Ray, just because they’ve had a very difficult first four years doesn’t mean we turn around and say, ‘Well, okay, we can’t ask you to treat your sister nicely.’” One of the biggest traps parents fall into is “he’s a special child,” and therefore my discipline becomes permissive or lax or overlooking. It doesn’t help anybody.


    This idea comes straight from a chapter in Dr. Ray’s first book, You’re a Better Parent Than You Think!

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.