Blog

  • Jesus Was Not a Good Man

    Jesus Was Not a Good Man

    Was Jesus just a good man or a good teacher? Dr. Ray, a psychologist, argues that “good man” is not a choice Jesus left open to us. He walks through why the apostles’ own lives and the content of Jesus’ teaching do not fit the theories that try to get around who he claimed to be.

    “Jesus was not a good man”

    Jesus was not a good man. You heard me right. Jesus was not a good man, if that’s all he was. If he were only a man, then he knew when he talked and acted like God that it was an act. He knew he wasn’t God. So really, he set people up to be punished and killed to follow him. If he truly thought he was God but he wasn’t, then he was similar to some of the people I used to assess at the state hospitals. He was crazy. He was either God, or he was something far worse.

    You can’t get around Jesus by saying he was a good man. That’s fascinating, because many of the intelligentsia, people at universities, folks who fancy themselves great thinkers, just declare, “Well, he was a good teacher, like Buddha, like Gandhi.” No, he wasn’t. He didn’t even know his identity if he wasn’t God. He was claiming to be something he wasn’t.

    So there’s no middle ground, as C.S. Lewis said. He didn’t intend to give us a middle ground. He either is who he said he is, or he’s a lot worse. He’s not a normal human being. That’s your choice.

    “Why are you going to be martyred for making stuff up?”

    Now, I have seen people try to get around this conundrum by saying that the stuff about him thinking and talking and acting like God, his followers put that in there. They wrote it in because they had to make him a little bigger than he was. He’s not just another rabbi guru. He’s getting a bunch of followers, getting thumbs up. We’ve got to make him bigger than he is if we have any chance of overthrowing the Roman Empire. We’ve got to go at this from a different angle. We can’t throw him over militarily, so we’ve got to figure out how to change hearts and minds. I know what we’ll do. We’ll make this guy God.

    That’s the thinking. I’ve heard that thinking. It’s a nice little speculative hypothesis by people who want to do away with having to make the decision regarding who Jesus was. But here’s a problem with that. We have pretty good historical evidence that the apostles, almost all of them, were martyred. You’re going to be martyred for making stuff up about a guy? You can give up your life for that?

    And here’s another thing. We know they traveled. Thomas, tradition tells us, was in India. Matthew, Africa. Wait a minute. If you’re trying to overthrow the Roman Empire, you don’t have to go to India. Nothing over there. What are you trying to preach? You’re trying to preach a lie that this guy was God? What for?

    So he either is who he said he is, or you can’t trust the Gospel as history. You don’t even have to trust it as God’s word. Just trust it as history. These guys wrote down the things he said and did, and you have to say that when they wrote it down, they wildly embellished it. And if you say that, you have to ask, like a good detective, what was their motive? Why? As far as we can tell, these guys were pretty faithful Jews. For them to declare that some guy was God, when they knew he wasn’t, they would be jeopardizing their eternal destiny. Jews didn’t do that. Jews were fearfully monotheistic. This makes no sense. None. Why would they jeopardize not only their souls but their lives? For what? To make up a bunch of stuff about this guy?

    Where is the craziness in his teaching?

    Here’s the other problem you have. Let’s just say he was crazy. Okay, then let’s look at what he said. Take away all the stuff where he was saying he was God, acting like God, talking like God. Just take his teachings, his parables. I’m a shrink. I’ve read them many times, not because I’m such a wonderful Bible scholar, but because I go to Mass. If you go to Mass for three years, you pretty much hear the whole Gospel.

    There’s not a whiff of craziness in what he talked about. Nothing. You would expect that if he’s crazy, this whole idea that “I’m God” would spill over into what he says about how to live your life. But it didn’t. What he said about how to live your life is sublime. It makes total sense. And whether psychology admits it or not, read my book, Jesus, The Master Psychologist. Research supports the kind of stuff Jesus said for more contented, stable, peace-filled living.

    So where’s the craziness in his teaching? Is this craziness only circumscribed in his self-identity? If you don’t know who you are, you are really crazy, because that is at the core of reality. Who are you? If Jesus said, “I’m God, that’s who I am,” then he’s crazy if he’s not God. Or he’s very calculating, if he knew he wasn’t God and figured, “I’ve got to get some followers. What’s the best way to do this?”

    But even that doesn’t make sense, because he’s not going to get followers by saying he’s God when he’s in a fiercely Jewish community that says, “Our God is one.” Why would you try to convince them otherwise? The only way he could convince them otherwise was to show it. He had to do things that they couldn’t account for. Miracles, signs, wonders, where they said, “How does he do this?” He’s claiming this, but yet he can do this. Even his enemies knew that. Even his enemies said, “Yeah, we’ll admit you do it, but you do it through the power of Satan.” And of course Jesus, as always, has a wonderful response. A couple of sentences, and he just shoots them down.

    So don’t let anybody tell your kids, if they go to college, or anybody you talk to, “Well, I’ll admit Jesus was a good man. He was a good teacher. He had a lot of nice ideas about how to live life.” You just look at them and say, “Well, you must not know much about the Gospels at all then.” Because that’s not even a possibility. He can’t have been just a good man.


    Dr. Ray makes the case for what Jesus taught in Jesus, the Master Psychologist: Listen to Him.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • Getting Cooperation from our Kids

    Getting Cooperation from our Kids

    Is it bribery to reward a child for going to bed cooperatively? Dr. Ray reacts to a podcast guest who said rewarding a four-year-old is far more effective than a consequence. He explains why he thinks it gets the order of cooperation and privileges backwards.

    What the podcast got wrong

    I listened to a fellow on a podcast last night. This guy has written some books on the formation of habits. It was good stuff, really was. He said a couple of things, though, that got me pondering.

    He used positive reinforcement, meaning putting a positive reaction or reward on something to increase the behavior that you want. And then he used the phrase “negative reinforcement” to mean putting a negative consequence on it. That’s not exactly right. I would have thought he would have known that. Negative reinforcement is the removal of something negative. So, for example, “If you do this, I will unground you.” That’s an example of negative reinforcement.

    But he said something that just makes me so uneasy, though I understand it because this is dominant psychological thinking. He said positive reinforcement is far more powerful than negative reinforcement. I think in the main that’s very true. However, the example he used gave me pause. He said if you want your four-year-old to go to bed, you say, “If you don’t go to bed cooperatively, tomorrow you lose your…” and then he named a device. My four-year-old wouldn’t have a device anyway, but that was the first place where I had a little trouble with it.

    He called that negative reinforcement: go to bed cooperatively, or you lose this. Then he said it would be far more effective, “twenty times more effective” I think was the phrase he used, to say, “If you go to bed cooperatively, I’m going to give you fifteen more minutes on your tablet tomorrow.”

    “It smells a little bit like bribery”

    I was ill at ease about that for several reasons. First of all, let’s just leave the tablet aside for a four-year-old, okay? That’s the first thing. Secondly, the implication, “I’m going to give you fifteen more minutes,” means how much time do you have to begin with? Now you’re giving them another fifteen? All right, those are really not the main issues.

    Here are the main ones for me. It would seem that you want to teach your children that cooperation, responsibility, and mature conduct are the condition for privileges and perks. In other words, your cooperation is what leads to the kinds of perks that you normally get. He chose to phrase the other side in terms of consequence. You should have used the word “punishment,” really. You can water it down by saying “consequence.”

    The other thing is this. It smells a little bit like bribery. If you cooperate in going to bed, if you don’t make this an hour and a half hassle, I’m going to give you something more. Well, why stop with that? Why not say, “Okay, I’ll let you stay up later tomorrow night”? I’ll let you watch an hour more TV. I’ll let you have two desserts instead of one. In other words, if you cooperate with me, I will pay you off. That just sits so badly with me in terms of trying to teach virtue.

    He was talking about establishing the habit. If you go to bed cooperatively, I will give you extra privileges. And I wanted to say, “Okay, are you going to do that every night? Are you basically going to say, ‘Every night I’m going to give you fifteen extra minutes on your tablet’?” I think he was really way off.

    Cooperation leads to perks and privileges

    Much of what he said was very helpful and useful. But again, I think he just reflected so much of the psychological thinking that is out there. I remember I got this when I was in grad school. Nothing but positive, nothing but positive. Reinforcement, reinforcement, reward, reward, reward. No consequences, no punishment. That was just pounded into us. And I remember being ill at ease then, before I even had forty years of experience with parents and kids.

    I think the main lesson you want to teach the kids is that cooperation leads to perks and privileges. That’s the order of things. It seems like he was reversing the order.

    Now, cooperation can lead to extra perks and privileges. You can say, “You know what? You were so cooperative last night. Tell you what I’m going to do today.” You can do that, but it’s a random thing, and it’s after the fact. It’s not before. If we go out to the restaurant and you’re really good, I’ll let you have extra dessert. Well, it would seem to me that getting dessert is a privilege, a perk. Heck, going out to eat in a restaurant is a perk. But if you’re pleasant and cooperative, yes, you’ll get the standard. We’re all going to have dessert and you’ll get it too. But if you’re not, that’s a privilege. Responsibility, cooperation, and pleasantness beget the stuff of your age. I think the other way just reverses it.


    Dr. Ray lays out his approach to discipline that builds character in Raising Upright Kids in an Upside-Down World.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • How do feelings change?

    How do feelings change?

    Can you change how you feel by changing how you think? Dr. Ray uses a Mark Twain quote and his own experience to show how thinking changes over the years, and how feelings follow. He applies it to a parent whose grown child has left the faith.

    “Has your thinking changed since age 14?”

    Mark Twain supposedly said this: “When I was 14, my father was so ignorant I could barely stand to have the old man around, but when I got to be 21, I was astonished at how much the old man learned in seven years.” Here’s the question that quote prompts. Has your thinking changed since age 14? How about since age 21? At that time you were pretty sure of the way you looked at things, right? What’s changed since? Probably a whole lot.

    You just don’t look at things now as you did then. Whether it’s religion, politics, life, emotions, people, or relationships, your thinking has radically shifted. What changed it? Was it reality? Was it personal experience? How about making mistakes, listening to other people, even your old man? Your thinking changes all the time.

    Thinking changes, and feelings follow

    So when people say to me, “I can’t help it, that’s the way I feel,” I’m tempted to say, “Well, wait, how did your thinking change from twenty years ago about all kinds of stuff?” Obviously you felt a certain way then. How come you don’t feel that way now? Because slowly, sometimes by getting hit with a two-by-four, you realize the way you were thinking is not good, doesn’t help you, causes problems for you, makes you feel bad, creates emotions that you don’t like. You start the process of saying, “I don’t want to think like that anymore. I want to accept that I can’t change that person. For years I felt terrible because that person was a certain way and I couldn’t do anything about it, but I don’t feel so terrible anymore.”

    Why? “Well, I guess I’ve just accepted that I can’t do anything about it.” How’d you accept it? What did you do? It wasn’t magic. You changed your thinking. You kept reinforcing to yourself, “I can’t do anything about that.” In the beginning you thought you could. Later on maybe you realized you couldn’t, but you were upset, devastated, frustrated because you so wanted to change that other person. You were desperate to change that other person. There’s got to be a way. Over time you realized, “No, I can’t. I tried every way I knew how. I even called that dude on the radio, Ray Guarendi.” He said, “Are you sure you can change that person?”

    So you came to accept, to your own peace, that you can’t do anything about that situation. Obviously your emotions changed with it. You’re not as disgruntled, not as unhappy, not as frustrated, not as ill at ease or lacking peace about the whole scenario. Because as you analyzed it, thought about it, and reassessed it, ever so slowly your thinking changed, and as your thinking changed, so did the feelings. They’re not as burdensome anymore. You’re not as hurt. You’re not as devastated.

    From evangelical to Catholic

    Your thinking does that all the time. Not just from when you were 14 until now. It does it from last year. When I was in the evangelical world, I was pretty certain that the way they looked at things, their particular theology, was pretty solid, pretty correct. Well, as I started to look at things, church history, church logic, church thinking, church theology, my thinking changed. Yes, there’s a lot of beauty in the evangelical world, but I found the Catholic Church made more sense to me. My thinking changed. That happens all the time.

    If you’ve got a kid who’s 23 years old and flat out doesn’t want to hear anything about religion, and you’ve been beating yourself up, “Where’d I fail? How’d I do this? What happened?” You thought you were doing right. Maybe you weren’t doing right. Maybe you missed something. You should have prayed the rosary in Aramaic, not English. But over a couple of years you became more at peace with the situation because you recognized, one, that you did what you thought was best, however imperfect and human, and two, that you’re not responsible for how he thinks. You can’t be. He doesn’t want to hear anything you have to say. If he did, maybe you could try to reach him, but he doesn’t want to hear it. Not at all. Zero, zip, nada.

    And ultimately your feelings of self-defeat and self-deprecation started to fade because your thinking changed. Feelings do not occur in a vacuum. They are fueled or tapered by the way we look at things.


    Dr. Ray goes deeper on how our thinking shapes our faith and our peace in Thinking Like Jesus: The Psychology of a Faithful Disciple.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • Is an Algorithm Raising Your Kid?

    Is an Algorithm Raising Your Kid?

    Is an algorithm raising your kid? Dr. Ray explains how the algorithms on phones and computers feed kids more of whatever they look up, and why he says the only way to stop it is to delay access.

    “Is an algorithm raising your kid?”

    I heard a great line the other day: “Is an algorithm raising your kid?” I just became familiar with algorithms in the last couple of years. They are a piece of, if you want to use the word brilliant, maybe seductive is a better word, technology that says in so many words, “I’m going to see what you’re interested in.” The algorithm finds out whatever you look up on your phone or your computer, and says, “Oh, they’d like to see more of that.”

    So if your 13-year-old, who shouldn’t have a smartphone but does, looks up something regarding gender confusion or same-sex attraction, the algorithm says, “That’s what they’re interested in. We want to keep them interested, because we can sell more things and make more money.” And it starts sending many more things about gender confusion and same-sex attraction their way. It isn’t stuff that says, “Let’s measure this and see what it’s all about and think why you’re thinking this way.” No, no, no. It says, “This is what you should be heading toward.” Or if you’re a curious 14-year-old boy and you go into a site that has inappropriate material, what do you know? You can have some more of that. We’ll feed you a steady diet of it.

    “Most parents don’t know that”

    The interesting thing about technology is that most people can’t keep up with it. It moves ahead so fast that the average parent is unaware of what the algorithm does. It says, “If you show an interest in this, we will send you much more of this. It’ll pop up on your feed, on your phone, on your computer.” So in essence, the algorithm has a very potent hand in raising your kid. Most parents don’t know that. Over 50 percent of parents have absolutely no safety mechanisms on that phone or computer.

    So the algorithm says, “Let me have your kid. I’ll tell you how your kids are going to think. You, mom, you, dad, you think you’re doing a fine job of this.” And then one day they’re 19 years old and you wonder how they got to the point where they think so differently than the way we tried to raise them. Ask the algorithm. If you type in something that has to do with some sort of antagonism toward religion, what do you know? You get all kinds of stuff. They’ll slam religion. Why? Because I want to keep you watching. I want to keep you attached. I want to keep you addicted. I hate to use that word, but let me use it for now. And before you know it, I’ll have you shaped into thinking the way I want, “I” meaning the algorithm.

    “The only way to stop it”

    So the only way to stop the algorithm is not to let it have access to your kid. And the only way to do that is to have the strength to say, “This isn’t good.” The only way to stop it is to delay the access to it. Even if I’m only one in a hundred parents that does it now, realize the strength that takes. It should make you mad, actually, that they’re doing this to your kid.

    I remember reading a book about this, and they were quoting a lot of the guys who developed the technology to keep kids hooked. They said, “There’s no way I would let my kid get on this stuff, because I know what it can do. I designed it.” They were pretty upfront about it. So once more, the question: is the algorithm raising your kid?


    Dr. Ray gives parents more on holding the line in Raising Upright Kids in an Upside-Down World.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • Affection Sends a Powerful Message

    Affection Sends a Powerful Message

    How do I show my kids my strict standards come from love? Dr. Ray tells dads that regular physical affection, even when teens resist it, softens the standards they enforce, and he shares what he did with his own son.

    “Loads of love”

    It’s not unusual to have your kids look around and see that the culture’s standards are lower than yours. Your goals as a parent, the things you want to teach, the way you approach raising kids is different from the bulk of people out there. If you’re raising, you hope, citizens for God’s kingdom, then your approach is going to be sometimes rapidly out of sync with the rest of the culture. Your kids know this, and some of them don’t like it, some of them don’t like it a lot.

    So what do you do? How do you convince them that what you’re doing is not because you’re bucking for the Tyrant Parent of the Decade Award, but because you love them desperately? I want to speak a little to the dads about this. It comes more easily to moms, I believe, but it’s very important, and more so when it comes from dads. How do you express to those kids on a regular basis that you are motivated by loads of love, and not by “I’m the boss, kid, my way or the highway, punk”?

    Affection sends a powerful message

    There are many ways, but I look back on my own fatherhood and I realize how very important this is: affection. Physical touch, hugs, kisses, “love you.” Moms do it a lot, and maybe as a group they do it more than dads. I am so convinced of the power of that to get across the message that my standards are different from the culture’s, but it’s because I love you so very much.

    It gets harder when they move into their teens, because the teen rules are: don’t embarrass me out in public, don’t touch me, don’t look at me, don’t say anything. I’ll just walk behind you by about 50 yards, and don’t turn around and look like you know me. We have allowed the kids to dictate how much affection we’re allowed to show them, especially out in public. One of the things that was critical for me as a dad was that I did not allow my children to decide when, where and how much I would show them affection. Not going to happen.

    “Try not to stink the joint out”

    My youngest son, Pete, went to St. Thomas Aquinas High School in Louisville, Ohio. His sophomore year he played basketball. He was 16. Before the home games I’d perch myself up in the fourth or fifth row of the bleachers and watch the kids horse around down there on the gym floor, guys doing what guys do, snapping each other with towels. I’d wait for an appropriate moment, and then I’d go down to Petey, grab him, hug him, and kiss him on the neck, on the cheek. And as a psychologist, I’ve realized it’s very important to be affirming and positive before a game like that. So I would always say, “Pete, try not to stink the joint out.” He would laugh.

    Afterwards I said, “Pete, I’ll bother you when I do that.” He said, “Would it make any difference, Dad?” I said, “No, it wouldn’t.” And then he told me later that a couple of his teammates came up to him and said, “I wish my dad would do that.”

    If you’re not an affectionate guy, nobody’s forcing you to not be affectionate. Maybe it doesn’t feel at ease, but it will feel at ease the more you do it. It sends such a powerful message to the kids: you’ve got to understand, son or daughter, how very much I love you and what you mean to me in my life. And that softens the standards you’re trying to get across and the way you’re enforcing things. They’ve got a smartphone and they’re 15 and they’re thinking, “How did I get stuck with this Neanderthal?” But it’s hard for them to deny all the affection coming their way. That’s hard to ignore.

    To this day, my son, he’s in his 20s, I hug him and kiss him almost every time I see him. And I’m Italian, so we hug and kiss. Message to the dads: it’s wonderful to have high standards. It’s wonderful to walk counter-culturally. It is. You should have an easier time of it if they know how much you love them, and they’ll know how much you love them by how much you show it.


    Dr. Ray offers more on parenting against the grain in Raising Upright Kids in an Upside-Down World.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.