Blog

  • Spiritual, but not Religious – Means Agnostic

    Spiritual, but not Religious – Means Agnostic

    What does “spiritual but not religious” really mean? Dr. Ray explains why he thinks the phrase sounds enlightened but is closer to agnosticism, and who ends up setting the terms.

    “I’m spiritual but not religious”

    Have you noticed that folks like to say things that sound enlightened and smart? But if you spent any amount of time thinking about them or analyzing them, they really are incredibly shallow and perhaps just flat out dumb. One of those, and I’m sure every single person listening has heard someone say it, is “I’m spiritual but not religious.” Maybe you’ve said it yourself at one point in your life. Hopefully you’re not still saying it.

    My first response to that is, what in the heck does that mean? You’ve got to define spiritual and you’ve got to define religious. So that’s the first problem: usually they’re self-defined. If anybody says that to you, you could start the conversation by asking, “What do you mean by spiritual?” And then, “What do you mean by religious?”

    When somebody says, “I’m spiritual not religious,” I think what they think they’re saying is, “I am not irreligious. I am not an atheist. I am closer to God, if he’s part of their spirituality, and a lot of times he isn’t, than this rote religion type stuff.” So while they mean to imply that they have some more mature kind of spiritual connection to whatever, actually it’s the opposite. They are closer to being agnostic.

    “I worship me”

    Dr. Ray, what are you talking about? Let me explain, Lucy. I’m spiritual. Spiritual to what? For many it just means, “Well, I believe there’s a higher power. There’s a higher something out there looking over us. This isn’t all there is.” Some of them may even say, “Yeah, I believe that something else is God.” Maybe not the God of the Bible, but the God. Given all that, they feel like they’ve got some kind of connection. They’re not just muddling along, paying no attention to anything other than what is here and now.

    Sometimes they will say, “I’m spiritual in the sense that I want a connection to something bigger than myself.” I was watching a sitcom once and she was trying to get her husband to go to church. He didn’t want to go, so he asked her, “Why do you go?” And she said, and I think this captures a vague spirituality, “Well, I just want to think there’s something bigger than ourselves, something more.” All right, that may be a tiny baby step toward God, but it’s meaningless, because what “I’m spiritual” ultimately means is I worship me.

    That’s not what it means, Dr. Ray? Of course it does. I define it. I say what’s spiritual. If I have a connection with the universe, or let’s take it all the way out: I like to pray, I believe there is a God, I even believe that Jesus is God. Take it all the way out and somebody calls that spiritual, and then they say, “But I want no part of religion.”

    Religion without any rules

    Now, here’s the other cliche. What do you mean by religion? Typically they mean rules, regulations, laws, responsibilities, and they want no part of that. All right, then who decides? Obviously you do. If you don’t want any part of what has been traditionally recognized as God in the flesh through Christ, or even if you’re not a Christian, the God who created the universe, if you don’t want any part of his recommendations for moral living, you just know that’s religion. And what do you follow? You follow you. In irony, you’re very religious. Why would I say that? Because you set the terms. If you set the terms on what spirituality is and what is not religious, then you’re 100% following them, because they’re yours. Why wouldn’t you?

    I think “I’m spiritual but not religious” is a way of saying, “Well, I don’t think this is all there is, but I still want to live the way I want to live. I still want to do it my way,” in the words of the song. So it’s a nice, enlightened-sounding out. I can decide which of these spiritual commitments I want to follow. I can be spiritual and have sex before marriage. I can be spiritual and believe that it’s OK to kill a baby in a womb. I can be spiritual and not pray but once a month and a half, if life throws something in my way and I better cry out to some being that’s up there somewhere in my spirituality. Yeah, I can do that. That’s all spiritual, isn’t it? Spiritual, meaningless. If it’s not attached to anything, it’s attached to me, the worship of the self.

    “Well, I just don’t buy these religions who stand between me and Jesus.” But what if Jesus said, “Here is how you connect with me. Here is how you follow me”? I can just imagine me saying to my wife, “Honey, I got to tell you, I am spiritually married to you, but I don’t really want any responsibilities, any kind of commitment, any kind of moral guidelines to this marriage. Just be satisfied that our marriage is spiritual.” How far would that go? Or with anybody: “Don’t ask me to do anything for you, but just know that I feel spiritual toward you. I feel connected. Well, if you’re sick and in the hospital, don’t ask me to visit you, because that’s kind of like a demand. That’s kind of like a responsibility, and that’s like a religious thing.”

    “I’m spiritual, but not religious.” That is one of the dumbest things that somebody can say. And the irony is it sounds so smart, it sounds so enlightened. They haven’t defined spiritual and they haven’t defined religious. And what’s worse is they’ve made religion into something that is not a beautiful way to connect with God and Jesus Christ.


    Dr. Ray tackles the hard questions about living the faith in everyday life in Family Faith Under Fire.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • The Teenager Stereotype

    The Teenager Stereotype

    Is the difficult teenager just a normal stage? Dr. Ray says he doesn’t believe surliness is automatic in the teen years, and tells why he thinks the stereotype is more cultural than developmental.

    “Well, that’s teenagers”

    My producer and I last week were talking about teenagers, because his daughter is 13. He said she’s a doll, she’s just a very easy kind of kid to raise. But he was talking to someone he knew whose teen was pretty surly and disrespectful. And the comment given to that parent was, “Well, that’s teenagers. That’s who they are. You’ve kind of got to weather it.” Or the room is a pigsty, so you just close the door. Of course, I don’t really know what a pigsty is. I’ve never really seen one. One comedian said his mother was an expert on pigsties. She would say, “This is the worst pigsty I have ever seen,” which raises the question, how many pigsties have you seen?

    The experts will tell you, and I’ve not done an official survey, but informally I would bet the majority would say, “Oh, let it go. It’s his domain. Shut the door.” Animals can gnaw through wood, but it’s your house. It may be the natural dishevelment of possessions of teenagers, but is it good?

    I don’t believe that “teenager just is.” In other words, that they get more argumentative or more surly about things, more difficult in their thinking. I don’t believe that is the natural progression. First of all, “teenager” is a relatively new term. For the most part, you just sort of grew up, and in many places in the history of the world, you didn’t even know your age. I remember we were talking to a missionary priest from one of the African countries, and I said, “Father, how old are you?” “I’m 72.” He looked like he was about 35. I said, “Father, you’re 72? Do you know when your birthday is?” “No, we don’t keep track of that.” So the whole idea of a certain persona unique to the teen years is a relatively new thing.

    More cultural than developmental

    I personally believe, after years of being in this business, that the stereotype of the more difficult teenager is not as much developmental as it is cultural. You parents who have younger kids, you hear these things: “Oh, enjoy them now. Those teenage years are right around the corner. My nine-year-old daughter loved me until she became 12.” And they scare you. Look out, here it comes. Nothing you’re going to do about it. They’re just going to act like this.

    Where I am sitting right now in this studio at Domino’s Farms, I don’t know how far back I would have to go to say this was a farm field or a meadow or a woods. But let’s just say it was a farm 150 years ago. Do you suppose that the farmer, when his boy turned 14, would be bemoaning to his friends, “Well, my son is 14. He’s one of them teenagers. He used to be real helpful, but now I can’t get nothing out of him. It’s hard to get him up in the morning. My other buddies are telling me the same thing. I’m just waiting until he gets to be 19 or 20 and decides he can be a little more help around here”? I don’t think so. I think that farmer was ecstatic that that boy was 14, because he was high energy, indefatigable, and could give him some real help around the place.

    I think one of the reasons that kids in their teens become a little more resistant to parents’ rules or limits or structure is they look around. Especially if you have standards and supervision that are different from the norm, they look around and they compare. They get resentful or upset or argumentative: “Why can’t I have that? Why can’t I do that? I’m 15. I should be able to do that. Everybody I know can do that.” And that breeds a sort of attitude. We use that word a lot with teens, don’t we? “Oh, she’s just got that attitude.” The word attitude has become pejorative, because if her attitude was, “Hello, Mother, how might I help you today?” you wouldn’t call it attitude, but that’s an attitude, just a good one. So we use the word attitude to describe their words, surliness, argumentativeness, whatever kind of demeanor. I just don’t believe that’s automatic with the adolescent years.

    “Oh, Dr. Ray, come on. Our hormones are kicking in. Boys get feistier. Girls may get a little more emotional and moody.” That is true. The body’s changed. I got that part. I just can’t fathom that it accounts for all of it.

    “Our children would never talk like that”

    I was in Cleveland once, checking in at a hotel. The clerk was a girl who, I found out, was from Nigeria. I asked her, “Are you here permanently?” She said, “No, I’m just here for school.” I asked, “What strikes you right away about our culture and your culture in Nigeria?” She didn’t hesitate. She said, “Your children.” What do you mean? “Our children would never be able to talk like that to their parents. Never. It wouldn’t be tolerated at all. It would be stopped.” I didn’t go into details on how they stopped it. She noticed it right away. Didn’t they have teenagers over there? Wasn’t adolescence and hormonal change happening over there? Now, again, this is just anecdotal. This is her perception, and I didn’t know what part of Nigeria she was from.

    My wife and I had 10 teenagers. They’ve all passed through teenagerhood, and at one time we had seven of them at the same time. Did we get a little more pushiness from the kids, getting to be more of what they want? Yeah, we did. But I’ve got to say, we did not have this idea of, “Man, I can’t wait till this kid grows up and gets through this phase.” I think part of it for us is we can tolerate it, but we don’t allow it. And our standards were probably different. We homeschooled, so right away standards are going to be different in a lot of respects from their general educated peer group.

    I guess the message of all this is, don’t be so quick to chalk it up to standard adolescence or teenagerhood that you have to wait to pass. Recognize you can address it, you can deal with it. And yes, you may get a little more of it, but it doesn’t have to characterize those years. Natural teen years, I’ll tell you what, they’re zestful, they’re bubbly, they’re fun, they’re energetic. At least that’s what it used to be before social media and the culture started telling them they’ve got to be dissatisfied and depressed. The natural persona of teens, would you like to have a lot of that energy back? That’s what it is. Don’t let anybody talk you into this: “Oh, that’s just the way they are. That’s how mine talks to me too. That’s just who they are.” No, it’s not just who they are.


    Dr. Ray goes deeper on raising teens with good discipline in Standing Strong: Good Discipline Makes Great Teens.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • The Payoff of Complaining

    The Payoff of Complaining

    Why do people complain so much? Dr. Ray looks at the internal and external payoffs of complaining, why chronic complainers push people away, and what complaining says about gratitude.

    The payoffs of complaining

    In my most recent book, How to Get Along with Almost Everybody, there’s a chapter on something called conversation killers. Complaining is one of them. But there has to be some payoff for complaining, otherwise, no payoff, people wouldn’t do it. So there are internal and external payoffs.

    The old country song says, “You can feel bad if it makes you feel better.” Is there something about complaining that is internally rewarding? Is it a rehearsal of, “Life hasn’t been good to me”? Is it a rehearsal of, “I’m not getting my fair shake”? Is it a rehearsal of, “I’ve got to voice this because I’m feeling emotionally so distressed that I’ve got to give words to it”? Something is internally rewarding about complaining.

    Maybe, though, it’s easier to understand the external rewards. When you complain, especially to people who care a lot about you, their tolerance for listening is longer. They will listen to your complaints because they love you and they’re concerned about you and they care what’s happening in your life. When you complain to somebody who really doesn’t know you all that well, their tolerance is a lot less. Why would they want to listen to what’s going bad for you, especially if what’s going bad for them in their mind dwarfs what’s going bad for you? And we’ll get to that in a second. Some people, when you complain, will commiserate. They will pull alongside of you empathetically and talk about how bad that is or how sad that must make you or how frustrated you are by that. They’ll do something or say something that is considered affirming to you, shrink talk. So there’s a reward to that.

    Why chronic complainers push people away

    Chronic complainers push people away. We’ve had so many calls on this program, and I get it with my folks in the office, where they won’t pick up the phone with relatives or friends because they just don’t want to hear 29 minutes of complaining. Complaining is also particularly grating when it’s nothing but complaining. It’s not an attempt to solve any problem. Any advice given is usually batted away, ignored, or countered: “I can’t do that.” Why? “Because I have this problem and this problem you don’t understand.” So complaining is less tolerable when the person doing the complaining isn’t interested in any kind of resolution to their complaints.

    But here is, I think, a much more subtle maleffect of complaining. In many cases, you don’t know who you’re complaining to, and you don’t know their circumstances. If this is a close friend or a relative, you may know some things about their life, but not everything. I had a client many, many years ago who came to me dealing with grief over her little nine-year-old daughter passing away from leukemia. One of the things she said was a revelation to herself is that her tolerance for other people’s complaining after her daughter’s death dropped dramatically, particularly if they were complaining about their kids. If she didn’t share with them the details, or even the death of her daughter, they had no idea. So they were complaining away to a woman who so desperately wanted to have her daughter back.

    A friend of mine told me that he went to a job interview, and a fellow was leaning back in his chair, staring out the window with his back to my friend. My friend walked in and the fellow said, “Have you ever had a really bad day?” That was an odd way to start an interview, my friend thought. He said, “Well, I guess I have. A lot of people have had bad days.” And the fellow turned and said, “You know, I thought that I had a lot of really bad days until I had a really bad day.” He turned around and his face was completely disfigured. He had been either trapped in a fire or something exploded, and he was nothing but scar tissue as they attempted to put his face back together. Of course, it was a face that got a lot of stares. It was a face that maybe scared little kids. And he complained a lot less about the stuff of complaining.

    Complaining and weak gratitude

    Complaining also is a sign of weak gratitude. Why am I going to focus on telling you all about how I have a problem with my big toe when in fact I can walk, or I have shoes? I saw a young man today at the dealership, probably somewhere in his mid-twenties. He walked in with a prosthesis on his left leg. It was a more modern one, not the old type, with a spring. He walked with a noticeable wobble, because of course you can’t replace a natural limb. I looked at that young man and thought, in all likelihood, given his age, he was in the military. Probably an IED. And I’m sitting there doing some writing with two good legs, and I’m thinking, yeah, okay, so I’ve got some problems in my knee here. I bet that guy wished he had problems in his knee.

    There’s got to be a payoff to complaining, both internally and externally. The key is to get rid of the payoff. To get rid of the payoff, you’re likely to complain less.


    Dr. Ray covers conversation killers like this one in How to Get Along with Almost Everybody.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • The Law of Lecturing

    The Law of Lecturing

    Why do lectures stop working on kids? Dr. Ray jokes about the parental lecture, explains why we give them, and says the longer the lecture, the less it is heard.

    Why parents lecture

    A staple of parenthood is the parent’s lecture, especially when the kids pull some stunt or do something that absolutely collides with the character you’ve been trying to teach. We feel desperate, and when we get desperate, we lecture.

    To us, a lecture really isn’t a lecture until it hits maybe 30,000 or 40,000 words. To kids, a lecture is anything that begins with “I want to talk to you” or “When I was your age” or “What were you thinking?” or “Listen up.” A compound sentence, that’s a lecture. Two independent clauses linked together by “and” or “but,” that’s a lecture. To them anyway.

    Why do we lecture? We think that given enough words, there’s going to be more persuasion. Somehow, some way, we will move through a chain of reasoning or cite other evidence that, as we proceed through the lecture, is going to essentially make a case. Maybe our first 800 words didn’t do anything, but who knows, 801 through 4,000 just might. We cling to the hope that we’re going to get through. I’m not saying we don’t. I would think that we would, approximately 1.62% of the time, but there’s always the hope, springing eternal.

    My mother’s lectures

    My mom was wonderful at lectures. “Raymond Nicholas Guarendi. How many times are you going to make me call you in here, Buster? You know, buddy boy, you seem to think I talk just to hear myself talk. You seem to think I like the sound of my own voice. I’m going to tell you something, you better listen and you better listen good, because I’m not going to say it again. I was not put on this earth to serve you. There are five other people in this house. You think we’re going to involve our schedule around yours? You mark my word, there are going to be some changes around here, because I am sick and I am tired. I have just about had you up to here. You don’t realize how good you’ve got it, but you’re going to find out something, because I’m going to tell you something else. You look at me when I talk to you. Don’t you look at me like that.”

    I didn’t really move. I mean, she wasn’t mad enough yet. My mother’s philosophy was, if the first 30,000 didn’t get you anywhere, double it. “You think you’ve got it tough? I am going to tell you what tough is. When I was a little girl, I used to walk 18 miles uphill both ways to school in a foot of nuclear waste with no shoes. We had one pair that glowed for 14 brothers and sisters. My turn only came around every two weeks, and I always gave my turn away. That’s the kind of girl I was. I got up at five o’clock in the morning, two hours before we were even allowed to go to bed, split a cornflake for breakfast with six brothers, carried the school on my back, did their homework along the way. You want to know something? I was grateful for what little I had.” What’d you have, Mom? “Nothing. Weren’t you listening? But we were happy children.”

    The law of diminishing returns

    The temptation to lecture is ever present. We just want to get through. We want to explain to them why we are parenting the way we’re parenting, why we think the way we think, why we don’t let them do what they want to do, why we do let them do what they don’t want to do. We just have to get through to them, to understand.

    You know the irony? As most kids get older, I’m talking seven, eight, nine, they do understand. At some primitive level, they do. They just don’t agree. That’s the difference. A client will be in my office with a 14-year-old, and I’ll say to the kid, “Would you please tell your mother why she has that rule?” And this kid says it better than I could say it. I get the smelling salts out, I revive mother, and I say, “What do you think of that?” She says, “Well, I never thought she understood it.” I say, “She always understood it, Mom.” She didn’t agree. There’s the difference.

    If you want to lecture, go ahead, but keep in mind, you get past a certain point where you’re not only getting no results, you’re probably regressing. Law of diminishing returns: the more you talk, the less you get listened to. Make your case, make it clear, ask if they have any questions, and then probably let it go, because after a while, you know what you sound like? Charlie Brown, when he’s holding up the phone, and you hear, “Want, want, want, want, want.” Or, and this is something I’ve noticed people do, they lecture their dogs. Did you ever notice that? “Now you get in here right now. What did you do? You see what you did in here? Are you allowed to do that in here? No, you’re not. And what happened the last time you…” And you know what the dog hears? “Blah, blah, blah, blah, Max, blah, blah, blah, Max.” Let the dogs give us a lesson. So if you want to lecture, go ahead, but keep in mind, the longer the lecture, probably the less it’s heard.


    Dr. Ray goes deeper on this in Discipline That Lasts a Lifetime.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.

  • Pick Your Battles!

    Pick Your Battles!

    Is “pick your battles” good parenting advice? Dr. Ray says it is fine for kid junk but a problem when it means letting disrespect go, and uses the broken window theory to explain why.

    What the experts say

    Never in human history has raising children been taken over by experts like it has in the last 40, 50, 60 years. The experts conveyed to parents that there are certain psychologically correct ways to raise children. And you parents, not being professionals, how do you know if you’re doing the right thing? I get that all the time from parents. Am I doing the right thing? Am I talking the right way? Am I saying the right things? Experts have all kinds of ideas and notions, almost as many as there are experts, and they have phrases to summarize their notions. There are a lot of them, but I’ll just pick one for this audio blog. “Pick your battles!”

    In other words, there are certain things as a parent that I assume they mean you should stand firm on, although they might think you should stand weak on things that you think you should stand firm on, because many experts are not religious and therefore don’t have your worldview. They say, in picking your battles, as a parent let some things go and then intervene and teach, or maybe, as a last resort, discipline. I have a real problem with “pick your battles.”

    Kid junk

    You can interpret it two ways. The first way I pretty much agree with. If the child is being a kid, he’s not doing anything wrong. He’s watching TV and he’s standing on his head. You may think to yourself, “What are you doing? Why are you standing on your head?” But he’s just being a kid. He doesn’t hurt anything. My son used to stand on his head in the crib when he was about two until he fell over and fell asleep. Or you send him to bed and he’s in bed but he’s just kind of singing to himself. He’s not getting out of bed. He’s not saying he has to go to the potty 26 times. He’s just kind of in bed singing. Is that a battle?

    I think a nice way to separate it out is kid junk, the stuff of kidhood, which isn’t irresponsible or immoral or hurtful to anybody else. Let it go. A lot of times we’re tempted as parents to pick on something, comment, nag about something that’s not wrong. There’s nothing bad about it. We just don’t like it. It irritates us. He’s outside running in circles. “Hey, settle down. Settle down. Why are you just running?”

    Where the experts trip up parents

    But here’s where I think the experts trip up parents. I’ll use a teenage example. Teens are notorious for rolling their eyes at parents, and that’s just viewed as standard teenhood. It’s what they do. They’ll grow out of it. That kind of demeaning disdain is, “Well, that’s standard adolescence. Let it go. Pick your battles. He’s not throwing a brick at you. He’s not cussing at you. He’s not screaming at you. He’s not being loudly disrespectful. He’s just rolling his eyes. Come on. Pick your battles.” That’s where I really have a hard time with experts. Basically, they say if it gets really serious in your eyes, then you do something about it. But the little stuff of disrespect, or the little stuff of mistreating a sibling, or the little stuff of not cleaning their room? “Pick your battles. Let the room go. It’s not a big deal. Who are you to ask that they keep their room clean?” I think that dramatically undercuts parents’ decision-making authority.

    We didn’t allow rolling eyes in our house at all. That’s disdainful. That’s nasty. That’s nonverbal disrespect. That’s basically a slap on the right cheek. When our Lord said, “Turn the other cheek,” he wasn’t talking about parents saying, “Well, okay, you can be disrespectful to me, kid. I’ll just turn the other cheek.” No, our role is to teach.

    I’ll draw a parallel. There was something called the broken window theory of law enforcement. This was tried, I believe, in New York City. For a while, the approach was, “Let’s just tackle the big stuff. Let’s just go after the larger rule-breaking offenses. The smaller stuff, couches on the curb that are set on fire, or broken windows in abandoned buildings, let it go. Pick your battles.” What they found was that translated into more rule-breaking of all kinds. When they took a zero tolerance toward the small stuff, “You’re going to get in trouble for setting a couch on fire. You’re going to get in trouble for breaking a window,” they found that the big stuff declined. Why? The theory was it conveyed an impression: someone is in charge. When all this little stuff, relatively speaking, but it’s still law-breaking, still vandalism, was allowed to go, it created an overall impression that there’s deterioration, nobody’s really in charge.

    I draw a parallel to parenthood. It creates an overall impression. The kid can roll his eyes at you, and you let it go. Is he going to stop there? “I rolled my eyes at you, but the next thing out of my mouth is going to be snotty.” “Pick your battles” is not good advice if you’re trying to teach virtue. It’s good advice if you’re letting a kid be a kid. Childhood stuff. It’s not hurting anyone, it’s not irresponsible, it’s not immoral. Just kid junk. There’s a lot of that. Pick your battles. Well, let me put it to you this way: that’s a phrase that I’m going to pick my battle about.


    Dr. Ray explains how to teach virtue and keep parental authority in Discipline That Lasts a Lifetime.

    Transcript of Dr. Ray’s audio blog, lightly edited for reading.